ford-macleod_thumb This article is more than 2 years old

Doug Ford’s Social Services Minister is ‘Demonizing’ Child Refugees to Cut Anti-Child Poverty Program, Advocates Say

‘It is being done to score political points with racist and xenophobic supporters’

Child and refugee advocates are accusing Doug Ford’s social services minister of scapegoating child refugees to deflect attention from new cuts to programs that support children living in poverty.

Last week, PressProgress was first to report on the Ford government’s cuts to the Transition Child Benefit, a program that provides up to $230 per month to help social assistance recipients who do not qualify for the Ontario Child Benefit access “basic necessities” like food and clothing.

Toronto City Manager Chris Murray warned the cut would primarily impact the families of “residents who may have recently lost their job” and “refugee claimants who have been in Canada for less than 18 months.” Murray warned the cut could make many of these vulnerable families homeless.

Advocates and officials in Waterloo, London, Grey County and elsewhere raised similar concerns about the cut.

In response to questions about the cuts, Children, Community and Social Services Minister Lisa Macleod told the Legislature this week:

“The Transition Child Benefit is provided to recipients who already receive social assistance but do not qualify for the Ontario Child Benefit. Primarily, they are refugee claimants and illegal border crossers.”

Macleod went further, suggesting the children of refugees are undeserving of public support and misleadingly characterizing child refugees as individuals who are in Canada “illegally”:

But I ask the member opposite back: Is it fair to give a taxpayer subsidy to those who are crossing the border illegally and will likely be deported? Is it fair to provide a taxpayer subsidy to those who do not file?”

Advocates for refugees say they are disturbed by the way Macleod is scapegoating child refugees to justify cuts to programs aimed at helping children in poverty.

“The government shouldn’t be using this opportunity to demonize those in need of protection,” Debbie Douglas, Executive Director of the Ontario Council Of Agencies Serving Immigrants, told PressProgress.

“The fact that refugee claimants, who have the right to apply for social assistance, are portrayed as taking advantage of the system is very troubling,” Douglas added, noting “it reinforces negative stereotypes about those in need of protection.”

Irwin Elman, the province’s outgoing child advocate, told PressProgress Macleod’s remarks are especially troubling because “hunger, shelter and the safety of children should know no border.”

“When a dollar becomes more important to protect than a life we must realize we have lost our way,” Elman said.

Osgoode Law Professor Sean Rehaag says Macleod’s comments are also inaccurate.

Rehaag told PressProgress statistics show a majority of refugee claims made by “irregular border crossers” are granted while many others acquire residency through the immigration process.

“So, in fact, a large proportion of this group will not deported,” Rehaag told PressProgress. “Instead, they (and their children) are likely to become permanent members of Canadian communities.”

Even then, Rehaag notes, “because the numbers of refugees coming to Canada are very small, this policy will not save a meaningful amount of money.”

The Osgood Law Professor suggests Macleod’s rhetoric is really designed to “score political points with racist and xenophobic supporters of the current government.”

Ford has faced accusations of anti-immigrant dog whistle messaging in the past, notably in 2018 when Ford’s campaign came under fire for declaring Ontario must “take care of our own” during a debate on immigration.

At the time, the right-wing third party advertiser Ontario Proud blanketed the province’s social media feeds with messages on anti-refugee themes.

Elsewhere, the government has also cut legal aid support for refugees in a move critics said could put Canada afoul of international law.

Ford’s government is already cutting a billion dollars from the Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services — including half a billion dollars in Ontario Works and ODSP financial support.


Help us protect Canadians by holding the powerful accountable.

Journalism is an important public service. That’s why PressProgress is prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable during the coronavirus pandemic.

Please consider supporting our award-winning non-profit news organization so we can keep making a positive impact for Canadians.


Support Our Journalism
PressProgress is an award-winning non-profit news organization focused on uncovering and unpacking the news through original investigative and explanatory journalism.

Most Shared

Copy of Thumbnail template Analysis

Erin O’Toole’s Plan to ‘Secure Pensions’ Could Allow Companies to Cut Pensions, Labour Experts Say

Related Stories


Tyler Shandro has Resigned. Here are His Worst Moments as Alberta’s Health Minister

View the post

Here’s What Canada’s 3 Major Parties’ Climate Platforms Mean for Workers

View the post

Here’s What Canada’s 3 Major Parties Say They Will Do For Workers and Labour Unions

View the post


Work & rights

Shanice Regis-Wilkins

How Labour Activists Pushed For Policies That Protect Workers and the Environment This Election

View the post
Equity & Politics

Erica Ifill

Why Justin Trudeau’s Strategy on Affordable Housing Isn’t Working

View the post
Human rights & inclusion

Amira Elghawaby

Why Immigrant, Newcomer and Racialized Communities Still Face Barriers to Voting in Canada

View the post