thumb-2026-04-01-jesse-brown
thumb-2026-04-01-jesse-brown This article is more than 7 months old
News

Jesse Brown Insists He’s Done Nothing Wrong

Banned from Reddit and accused of phishing critics, Canadaland’s founder is leading a chaotic 'investigation' into an army of sockpuppet accounts

Jesse Brown thought something fishy was going on with Reddit.

According to the founder, publisher, editor-in-chief, spokesperson and public voice of the Canadaland podcast network, someone told him the “vast majority” of messages on a subreddit devoted to the media critic’s podcast might be coming from an army of fake sockpuppet accounts run by just one guy.

“Some months ago I was made aware of an alleged astroturfing effort against Canadaland,” Brown recently told PressProgress. “I learned that one individual might be operating a number of anonymous accounts and presenting each account to the public as a separate individual.”

“These accounts were responsible for the vast majority of the posts on the Canadaland subreddit, and a high percentage of the comments.”

Brown, who stressed he normally takes a “hands-off approach to anonymous online criticism,”  decided to undertake a “simple investigation” to determine if most of the messages on a social media forum devoted to discussing his own podcast were secretly being orchestrated by “one individual.”

That’s when a bizarre email appeared in the inbox of one of the podcaster’s longtime outspoken critics.

Email from Jesse Brown to Mark Bourrie

Dr. Mark Bourrie, the celebrated Governor General’s award-winning author and sometimes lawyer, said he received a “creepy” email from Brown late one night last month asking him to comment on a story.

The email contained a link to a page on Canadaland’s website simply titled “Bourrie.”

“When I clicked the link, it took me to a page with a 50-year-old picture of me, taken from a Penetanguishene Secondary School yearbook,” Bourrie told his social media followers.

“Somehow, Jesse Brown got one of my yearbook pictures. From 1974.”

Image of Canadaland’s “Bourrie” page

Bourrie later received an 11 PM phone call from Brown “accusing me of posting on Canadaland’s subreddit.” He said Brown read out a list of “Reddit names that I have never heard of.”

“Brown named off about five or six Reddit accounts,” Bourrie told PressProgress. “He said he had evidence from an expert that those accounts were mine. I told him he needed a better expert, since this was wrong.”

Bourrie “offered to swear an affidavit to that effect,” describing this as a “big offer” from a lawyer. “I’m a lawyer and would be in serious trouble with the Law Society of Ontario if I swore a false affidavit.”

“He was insistent that the accounts were mine and said my ‘denial’ would be ‘noted’ in the story he claimed to be working on,” Bourrie recalled. (Brown has not yet published any findings from his investigation into Canadaland’s subreddit and denies making any accusations about Bourrie – “at this time I have made no such accusation.”)

Bourrie, who has butted heads with Canadaland over their past reporting about him and once created a blog that devoted significant space to criticizing Canadaland’s coverage of Craig Kielburger’s WE Charity, adamantly denies any involvement in a Reddit astroturf campaign.

“I have never had a Reddit account and have never posted on any Reddit sites including r/Canadaland,” Bourrie told PressProgress.

“I don’t know of any campaigns against Canadaland on Reddit.”

As it turns out, Bourrie wasn’t the only one who began receiving strange messages.

Modmail message sent to several r/Canadaland subreddit users

Around the same time, a number of users on the r/Canadaland subreddit (which is run independently from Canadaland) also began receiving messages from a moderator requesting advice from “top posters on this sub” about links to Canadaland’s website containing internal company documents.

“I’ve been made aware of four unlisted pages on Canadaland.com,” said a message sent through the subreddit’s moderator mail function. “I’m not sure they want them to be made public. Here is one of them.”

The links, which led to pages displaying excerpts from a draft copy of Canadaland’s journalistic standards policies along with editorial feedback from Brown, appear to have been sent with Brown’s knowledge.

NotIan, r/Canadaland’s former moderator, confirmed taking the unusual step of granting Brown’s team temporary moderator powers last month after the media critic contacted him about “weird posts” on Canadaland’s subreddit.

“Jesse reached out about doing an investigation into weird posts on the subreddit,” NotIan told PressProgress. “He was saying there were certain posts, and certain comment threads that seemed to be coming from one person. Specifically Mark Bourrie.”

“I agreed to give them temporary mod access to investigate,” NotIan acknowledged, but said shortly thereafter someone acting on Brown’s behalf began using the subreddit’s moderator messaging system to send messages to individual subreddit users.

In addition to the self-leaked internal documents, something else was hiding in the strange links sent to both Reddit users as well as Bourrie – tucked away in the source code of the webpage was a special javascript code connected to a tracking tool called “TraceMyIP.”

Canadaland was quietly logging the IP addresses of anyone who clicked on the links.

Canadaland’s “Bourrie” page displaying a TraceMyIP icon

TraceMyIP, a company created in 2008 and registered in Orlando, Florida, provides free and paid online tools designed to collect metadata on visitors to websites.

“TraceMyIP can collect their public IP address, internet service provider, general geographic region, and device details like the browser and operating system,” Slav Vaskevich, TraceMyIP’s creator, explained to PressProgress.

Message recipients suspected something was off after noticing a small icon with TraceMyIP’s logo in the bottom corner of the linked pages – something that does not appear on other pages on Canadaland’s website.

According to the subreddit’s moderator mail logs, four subreddit users each received unique links to pages on Canadaland’s website. Other subreddit users reported receiving similar links through direct messages, though the accounts that sent them were quickly deleted and it remains unclear who sent those.

One Reddit user named Some-Background1467 was one of the four subreddit users targeted in the modmail sting, a detail confirmed by the subreddit’s modmail logs. They deny that they are Mark Bourrie and say the experience has left them angry and deeply unsettled.

“A lot of us feel betrayed by the mod,” the Reddit user told PressProgress, adding they were also “angry at Canadaland for breaching our trust” and “being needlessly invasive.”

“There are terrible things that do get said on this subreddit sometimes,” they conceded, but added that what they “don’t understand is why people here are being targeted.”

Lorax Horne, a journalist and data activist who previously ran the whistleblower website DDOS Secrets, is one of multiple subreddit users who received direct messages from anonymous accounts containing the same links. Horne, who also freelanced for Canadaland in the past, uses a pseudonymous username on Reddit and doesn’t believe Brown would have any way of knowing who they were.

“I don’t care if Jesse knows I am one of the sockpuppets he tried to dox,” Horne told PressProgress, explaining their reason for agreeing to identify themself by their real name.

Horne said the direct message they received had every appearance, in their view, of being an attempt to “entrap critics into giving up personal information about themselves.”

Jesse Brown’s banned Reddit account

Following revelations Brown gained moderator powers and began messaging subreddit users, Brown’s account was suddenly banned by Reddit and the entire r/Canadaland subreddit was locked down.

A Reddit spokesperson confirmed to PressProgress that both Brown and the subreddit’s moderator were banned for violating Reddit’s rules and moderator code of conduct, prompting r/Canadaland to be considered unmoderated and listed as restricted.

NotIan, r/Canadaland’s former moderator, said he received a notice from Reddit indicating he was banned from the platform for “breaking the rules” but was given “no indication of which rule.”

“I’m very displeased and have appealed my ban,” NotIan told PressProgress.

“I use Reddit a lot, and the Canadaland subreddit was only a small part of my usage. I am hoping to get my account back, and am pretty irked by all parties, Canadaland and the users who were complaining.”

HTML source code containing IP tracer on Canadaland page

In addition to Mark Bourrie and a handful of Reddit users, a number of journalists also began receiving strange emails around this time from a mysterious individual calling themselves the ‘Canadaland Tipster’.

It remains entirely unclear who the Canadaland Tipster actually is, but several journalists confirmed the Tipster account sent them messages similar to those sent to users on the Canadaland subreddit.

Karyn Pugliese, a journalist with the Aboriginal Peoples’ Television Network and Canadaland’s former Editor-in-Chief, was one person the Canadaland Tipster contacted with links to the journalistic standards policy Pugliese herself helped draft in 2024. Pugliese said she received the message first on Bluesky, and through the Protonmail account “[email protected].”

At first glance, Pugliese thought the Canadaland Tipster was a Canadaland union member leaking the document in advance of collective bargaining (Canadaland’s union negotiated a journalistic standards policy in their previous agreement, though the version of the policy she drafted wasn’t implemented). Pugliese confirmed the text that appears on Canadaland’s website is the same that appeared in the Google Doc she drafted along with Brown’s feedback.

While it’s unclear who the Canadaland Tipster is, it’s clear to Pugliese that the decision to upload a document to Canadaland’s website that has her name on it was a choice.

“He could have put up any document there,” Pugliese told PressProgress. “He could have put up a Canadaland report, he could have put up a picture of himself, he could have put up a picture of Mark Bourrie, he could have done anything, but he chose a document that had my name on it.”

“I feel particularly targeted,” Pugliese said, adding that after learning about the IP tracing tool embedded on the site, she said “it feels like there was an attempt to get my IP address.”

Image of  Canadaland’s original draft Journalistic Standards (Google Docs)

Pugliese later learned she wasn’t alone.

PressProgress has independently confirmed the so-called Canadaland Tipster sent emails with the same links and the same IP tracer to several other journalists, including Rachel Gilmore, Nora Loreto, Scott Martin, Ethan Cox, Jimmy Thomson, The Maple, as well as the reporter of this story, Luke LeBrun.

Some journalists were so spooked out by the emails that they had their phones scanned for spyware as a precaution. “No trackers or anything were placed on it by clicking on that link,” Loreto told PressProgress.

Brown admits to sending messages to Mark Bourrie and several Reddit users as part of an investigation that involved “IP tracking,” but the media critic flatly denies any involvement in or knowledge of any emails sent to the several other journalists, including Pugliese and Loreto.

“No, I’m not,” Brown told PressProgress when asked directly if he is the Canadaland Tipster. “The tipster email address has nothing to do with the investigation.”

Canadaland later issued a public statement explicitly denying they sent “phishing” emails to journalists:

“It has been alleged that an employee of Canadaland sent “phishing” emails to various media personalities from an anonymous email account, [email protected]. This allegation is false. Canadaland had no association or involvement with the CLTipster email account and no awareness of its actions.”

Asked by PressProgress if their true identity is Jesse Brown, the Canadaland Tipster issued a more terse response: “That’s a serious allegation – one you’d want to be able to substantiate before publishing.”

The Canadaland Tipster soon after deactivated their email account. The links with IP tracers contained in the Tipster’s email remain live on Canadaland’s website.

Email from the Canadaland Tipster

Claudiu Popa, an online privacy and cybersecurity expert who reviewed the links to Canadaland’s website, said although the IP tracer does not appear to be a particularly “sophisticated” technology, the way in which it is being used is concerning.

“This is not advanced spyware, a zero-click exploit, or a custom intrusion vector,” Popa explained to PressProgress. “What makes this more concerning is not the technical sophistication in the narrow sense, but the apparent selectivity of the targeting.”

“In other words, the novelty is not in the tool, but in the use case: taking a relatively accessible tracking product and using it in a way that appears designed to profile a specific set of recipients. That can still be intrusive and intimidating even if the underlying technology is not especially advanced.”

Popa noted the IP tracer “does not automatically identify a person, but it can be useful to correlate users who open emails with bulletin board commenters”

The creator of TraceMyIP echoed Popa’s observations, cautioning that while his tool could, in theory, be used to identify and correlate IP addresses, this data would at best be “circumstantial evidence.”

“An IP address alone rarely provides a specific home address or a person’s name,” Vaskevich pointed out. “Many users on mobile networks or in office buildings share the same public IP address, and others may use a VPN to mask their true location.”

“Creating ‘nothingburger’ pages solely to capture a target’s data is often categorized as a form of phishing,” Vaskevich said. “Moving from passive, site-wide analytics to creating targeted links meant to lure a specific individual into a digital ‘ping’ moves the tactic into a much more aggressive category.”

Vaskevich made clear he does not endorse using his tool in this way as it raises “significant concerns.”

Brown rejects any notion his “investigation” was targeted at his own critics or that he crossed any lines, noting Canadian privacy law does not apply to information collected for journalistic purposes. He also insists it was the sockpuppet accounts that “crossed the line from criticism of our journalism into misinformation, personal attacks against our staff members and racist diatribes.”

“Every code of journalistic conduct I have read considers undercover reporting ethical when circumstances require it,” Brown told PressProgress. “The specific investigative method I used, IP tracking, has been employed by various news organizations over the years, including the Ottawa Citizen.”

In 2012, the Ottawa Citizen used a similar tactic to identify a Liberal Party staffer who had been leaking salacious details about then-public safety minister Vic Toews’ divorce on Twitter. While that investigation was limited to a single Twitter account, it too sparked public debate.

Image of TraceMyIP dashboard (YouTube)

A good deal of confusion may owe to the fact Brown has repeatedly denied he is the Canadaland Tipster or knows who sent several journalists messages resembling phishing emails, but also simultaneously admits to “sending messages to four Reddit accounts and to one individual – Mark Bourrie.”

Brown insists Canadaland will be “publishing the results of that investigation soon” and promises that all questions will be answered in due course.

Others aren’t so sure. And they remain skeptical it was pure coincidence they were contacted.

Ethan Cox, a senior editor at Ricochet and one of the journalists contacted by the Canadaland Tipster, says Brown’s investigation is, in his view, anything but normal.

“These are not acceptable investigative techniques for a journalist to use,” Cox told PressProgress, likening the use of deceptive emails and IP tracers to a “honeypot” or a “harebrained espionage scheme.”

“It appears to have been a fishing expedition to identify critics,” Cox said, pointing out that a common thread linking many of the people who were sent links is a past history of making critical comments about Brown or reporting on Brown’s activities.

For Karyn Pugliese, Canadaland’s former Editor-in-Chief, the episode raises bigger questions about journalistic concepts like the public interest and public trust.

“I don’t know what the public interest was here, or if that was given thought,” Pugliese told PressProgress. “There were private people out there who, as far as I can see, didn’t do anything wrong, and had their privacy breached, or attempted to breach their privacy, and feel tricked.”

“The public is discussing it, and they feel like this is untrustworthy,” Pugliese added. “And, you know, then it makes it that much more difficult for the rest of the media to have to go out and explain what we do, why we do it and what our ethics are.”

Mark Bourrie, meanwhile, simply doesn’t understand why Jesse Brown posted a yearbook photo of him as a Grade 10 or 11 teenage boy on Canadaland’s website.

“It seems like a rather gross invasion of my privacy,” the 69-year-old author told PressProgress. “It seems very strange that a news outlet that claims to do media criticism would think it’s newsworthy to dig up my old yearbook.”

“The whole experience was strange and creepy.”

Whatever Brown’s level of involvement may or may not be, Cox thinks it’s simply “jaw-dropping conduct from someone who once presented himself as the watchdog of media ethics.”

“This behaviour crosses significant red lines,” Cox said.

“I think Jesse Brown owes me, and a lot of other people, an apology.”

 


 

Update: This article was updated after it was first published to note National Observer Editor-in-Chief Jimmy Thomson also received an email from the ‘Canadaland Tipster’.

 

Our journalism is powered by readers like you.

We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.

Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.

 

Become a member
Luke LeBrun
Editor
Luke LeBrun is the former Editor of PressProgress. His reporting focuses on federal politics, right-wing media and far-right extremism.

Most Shared

Second Sons ANALYSIS

Why the Flight Attendants’ Strike Was 'A Perfect Storm' for Labour

Related Stories

NEWS

Pediatric patients with complex chronic illnesses impacted by BC’s quiet changes to virtual care

View the post
NEWS

Lawsuit alleges top executive hired to address sexual harassment in BC paramedicine terminated while on maternity leave

View the post
NEWS

BC teachers say public education is being overlooked in the provincial election campaign

View the post
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.