BC_Ambulance_at_RCH
BC_Ambulance_at_RCH
NEWS

Lawsuit alleges top executive hired to address sexual harassment in BC paramedicine terminated while on maternity leave

Hiring prompted by report calling for 'urgent attention' to address harassment and low morale

Plans to address sexual harassment and low morale amongst BC’s paramedics may have hit a snag after an executive hired by the province’s health authority to address those issues was terminated while on maternity leave.

A lawsuit filed in BC’s Supreme Court last month alleges that Agnieszka Peel was poached from her executive director position at BC Ferries in 2023 by the Provincial Health Services Authority (PHSA) and BC Emergency Health Services (BCEHS) for an executive-level position in BCEHS’s human resources department, only for the position to be terminated while Peel was on maternity leave two years later. 

The position offered to Peel — Chief of People, Culture and Diversity — was new to the organization, its creation spurred by recommendations in the Gaskell Report, which urged BCEHS management to address sexual harassment and low morale in BC’s paramedicine sector. 

“The breadth of sexual harassment activity reported, and the sense of frustration expressed by a number of female paramedics, as well as acknowledgement by male colleagues of its existence, requires urgent attention and a sustained focus on to reduce, by the organisation,” wrote report author, Cathe Gaskell, in the executive summary.

According to the lawsuit, PHSA and BCEHS were trying to implement “necessary organizational and operational changes” in order to improve the work culture in paramedicine and increase awareness of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI).

The position would oversee human resources, labour relations, DEI, culture and employee experience and would make Peel responsible for the HR, Labour Relations and Recruitment department of 50 people.

But the lawsuit argues that the position was not as it was sold to Peel. According to court documents, major components of the role were misrepresented and there was clear internal disagreement about the scope of the role and its power. 

Peel was on maternity leave when she found out that PHSA leadership undertook multiple reviews of her job without her knowledge, court documents state. The reviews focused on the Gaskell recommendations that led to the creation of the role, whether to maintain the position, and whether to ‘reinstate’ Peel at the end of her maternity leave.

The lawsuit alleges that Peel was not given the opportunity to provide input on whether the role should be maintained, or whether she should be “reinstated” at the end of her maternity leave. BCEHS also didn’t hire a replacement for Peel’s maternity leave, despite Peel’s concerns about the “negative impact this would have on the cultural changes,” and labour and human resources initiatives Peel was hired to implement.

Peel was in the last weeks of her leave when her employment was terminated without cause. She received an eight month severance package and has been unemployed since.

Peel is suing PHSA and BCEHS for negligence and negligent misrepresentation, wrongful dismissal, breach of the duty of good faith and breach of the Human Rights Code, claiming that her pregnancy and/or maternity leave were factors in her position’s termination. 

Sexual harassment and bullying issues “need to be prioritized”: Gaskell Report

The Gaskell Report was released via a Freedom of Information (FOI) request and then published on the BCEHS website in early July 2023, a year after it was completed. Because the report was released via FOI, some details, like names, contact information and some testimonies, are redacted for privacy reasons. 

The report’s author, UK-based consultant Cathe Gaskell, reviewed BC EHS policies and training materials, workforce data, employee surveys, met with the Women in Paramedicine Special Interest Group and interviewed paramedics. 

The report addressed a wide variety of issues in BC’s paramedicine sector — including relations between workers and management, payroll and scheduling issues, trauma from responding to the 2021 heat dome and insufficient data collection — but it stressed that issues around sexual harassment, bullying and low levels of diversity awareness “need to be prioritized… to stop further deterioration and the impact on both the organizations morale and reputation.”

Gaskell also wrote that low-levels of DEI awareness and a lack of sensitivity to the diversity of both colleagues and patients is “likely to be creating tensions in the workplace.” 

In reviewing BCEHS’s workforce data collection, she found that the organization only collects data on gender and age. The report’s recommendations include collecting data on ethnicity, recruitment and retention, sick-leave and complaints that get referred to regulators. 

According to the Women in Paramedicine Special Interest Group, 40% of the BCEHS workforce are women. 

Gaskell wrote that it’s a “reasonable conclusion” that sexual harassment is underreported by BCEHS, and that in interviews, a number of staff expressed that complaints about such harassment “will not be acted upon or taken seriously.”

“Anecdotally it was reported that females had been treated poorly when raising complaints as this had resulted in both direct and indirect reprisals,” Gaskell wrote. “For some it remained a terrifying prospect to consider raising a complaint about sexual harassment.”

A 2022 BCEHS staff survey that Gaskell reviewed for her report found “extremely low” morale amongst paramedics because of the lack of acknowledgement from leadership and burnout.

“There appears to be consistent sentiment that leadership does not value BCEHS, due to a lack of recognition or business decisions that do not support BCEHS and a lack of visibility or listening to employees.”

A number of recommendations in the report point to the creation of a role like Peel’s. Gaskell noted that “engaging with staff to deliver long term change might involve creating new roles such as diversity champions.” 

Gaskell also recommended the implementation of a ‘sexual harassment in the workplace’ policy, a People Strategy and a Gender Equality Strategy, the latter of which commits the organization to fairness and equity for women paramedics, which included providing assurance on how to manage, report and reduce sexual harassment over a 2–5-year period.

Gaskell stipulated that there should be quarterly reports on how the work of eliminating sexual harassment and gender bias is progressing.

After the report was released to the public, BCEHS told CBC News that the organization had already begun improving its hiring practices and creating training strategies to address issues brought up in the Gaskell Report.

“We’ve been focusing on trying to make sure our culture is more diverse,” Leanne Heppell, chief ambulance officer for the BCEHS, told CBC News. “Certainly, we have a lot more to do to ensure that we are providing equitable services for all cultures and for women as well.”

In response to questions from PressProgress, a representative from BCEHS, writing on behalf of both BCEHS and PHSA, confirmed that the organizations are aware of Peel’s claim. “As the matter is before the courts, it would not be appropriate to comment publicly on the allegations. Any response will be provided through the legal process.”

As of publication, the BC government is in a post-election interregnum period, meaning communications are limited to “critical health and public safety information.”

PressProgress reached out to Peel’s lawyer but did not receive a response. 

When contacted by PressProgress for comment, the union representing BC’s paramedics, the Ambulance Paramedics of British Columbia (CUPE 873), did not respond.

 

Our journalism is powered by readers like you.

We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.

Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.

 

Become a member
Emma Arkell
Associate Editor
Emma Arkell is PressProgress' Associate Editor. Her reporting focuses on the construction trades, workplace health and safety, low-wage workers and corporate influence on labour policy.

Most Shared

Second Sons ANALYSIS

Why the Flight Attendants’ Strike Was 'A Perfect Storm' for Labour

Related Stories

NEWS

Pediatric patients with complex chronic illnesses impacted by BC’s quiet changes to virtual care

View the post
NEWS

BC teachers say public education is being overlooked in the provincial election campaign

View the post
NEWS

BC Conservative candidate Heather Maahs defends blog post about “slave auctions” and blackface in Chilliwack schools

View the post
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.