dougford-ontariopcs_thumb
dougford-ontariopcs_thumb
Analysis

These Ontario PC MPPs Swore They’d Stop Someone Who Acts Like Doug Ford. Now They’re Suddenly Quiet.

Will the Ontario PC caucus hold their out-of-control leader accountable or are they willing to go down with him?

September 11, 2018

Do Ontario’s Progressive Conservative MPPs believe in anything?

This week, Ontario’s Superior Court ruled Premier Doug Ford’s plan to gerrymander Toronto’s political boundaries in the middle of an election is undemocratic and unconstitutional.

So, Ford accused the courts of being undemocratic and threatened to invoke the notwithstanding clause to override the Constitution whenever he feels like it if courts keep striking down his laws as unconstitutional.

But don’t worry, Ontario – the Ontario PC caucus is full of strong, independent-minded MPPs who will surely stand up to a belligerent government ignoring the courts and using strong-arm tactics its to rig a democratic election, right?

Here are a few Ontario PC MPPs who claim they support the Constitution and the rule of law, but don’t seem to be doing anything to check their own government’s abuse of power:

Randy Hillier

Surely one man willing to stand up to Ford’s despotic instincts is Randy Hillier.

As the founder of the Ontario Landowners Association, Hillier used to erect billboards across the Ottawa Valley warning the government to “back off,” so if Ontario can count on anyone to stand up to a tyrannical government running roughshod over the rule of law – Randy Hillier is the man!

While Ford said the courts have no authority to strike down his government’s unconstitutional laws because he won a majority government, Hillier once sensibly stated “the rule of law guarantees freedom and protection to minorities from the tyranny of the majority.”

“We cannot let our guard down,” Hillier added. “We must forever be diligent.”

Hillier also led a push to declare a new holiday called “Constitution Day,”  noting that it represents “the only laws that restrain government” – presumably including Hillier’s own government.

Christine Elliot

Some see Health Minister Christine Elliott as more of a “moderate Red Tory” next to Ford and she does talk a good game about being “vigilant of those who stand against freedom, democracy and the rule of law,” but what’s any of that really worth if she just goes along with Ford every time he overrides the Constitution?

“Our rule of law depends upon the effectiveness of our justice system,” Elliott says.

Oh?

Monte McNaughton

Then there’s Infrastructure Minister Monte McNaughton, who once accused the government of failing “uphold the rule of law” when he sided with campers over an Indigenous group in a land claim dispute – so, surely McNaughton is equally concerned about a government trying to rig an election, right?

After all, McNaughton reminds us you can’t “pick and choose who is subject to the rule of law.”

Paul Calandra

And what about Paul Calandra?

When you think about a man of integrity standing up and holding government to account, who doesn’t think about Stephen Harper’s ex-parliamentary secretary?

Calandra has been very, very clear that the government has a “constitutional obligation” to “support the Constitution” and “make sure that we pass laws in accordance with the Constitution.”

Calandra even suggests this is a principle he would “fight for” because “that is what a government must do.”

 

Daryl Kramp

Another person Ontarians can surely count on to defend their rights is Ontario PC caucus chair Daryl Kramp.

Kramp, a former Conservative MP who led the committee responsible for studying Stephen Harper’s Bill C-51, has long been a believer that “our legal people follow the rule of law” because that is “the manner that justice is carried out in Canada.”

No doubt Kramp is organizing his caucus to push back against Ford’s overreach, given that he often reminds us that Canadian women and men in uniform are defending “freedom, democracy and the rule of law.”

So Kramp’s going to speak out against Ford overriding the constitution to interfere with a municipal election too, right?

 

Invest in our work

We break news and shine a light on stories Canada’s major media outlets miss. But we need your help to keep making an impact.

Subscribe to our Friday Newsletter

Too busy to follow the daily news? Get the inside scoop on the entire week’s news sent to your email inbox every Friday at noon.

Invest in our work

We break news and shine a light on stories Canada’s major media outlets miss. But we need your help to keep making an impact.

dougford-courtruling_thumb
dougford-courtruling_thumb
News

10 Most Damning Quotes From the Court Ruling Striking Down Doug Ford’s Law Rigging Toronto’s Election

Ontario’s Superior Court just ruled Doug Ford’s gerrymandering law is undemocratic and unconstitutional

September 10, 2018

Doug Ford’s last minute attempt to rig Toronto’s municipal elections has been overturned by an Ontario court.

In a decision delivered Monday morning, Ontario’s Superior Court struck down Ford’s legislation eliminating half of Toronto City Council in the middle of an election, ruling the move is “unconstitutional.”

Ford’s controversial Bill 5 gerrymandered Toronto’s political boundaries, reducing the number of wards from 47 to 25 – a move that would have heavily shifted power to suburban…