kenney-coffeebreak_thumb
kenney-coffeebreak_thumb
Fact-Check

‘Shameful’ and ‘Disrespectful’: Experts Call Out Jason Kenney’s False Statements About Healthcare Workers

UCP leader complained surgeons spend too much time 'scrubbing' equipment and taking 'coffee breaks'

March 1, 2019

Jason Kenney managed to anger some of Alberta’s leading healthcare experts and medical practitioners after a video surfaced showing Kenney complaining that public healthcare workers “waste” too much time and money sanitizing equipment and going on coffee breaks.

Speaking at the Whitecourt Chamber of Commerce last year, Kenney argued that  private healthcare is faster than public healthcare, claiming without providing any evidence that private clinics can do twice as many joint surgeries every day.

“They do the procedure, they shut it down, they turn off the light, they scrub it, they go on a coffee break and they come back,” the UCP leader said of surgeons in the public healthcare system.

“This is a huge waste of capital. The human capital as well as the overhead.”

Last week, Kenney unveiled his plan to expand private healthcare in Alberta.

Cameron Westhead, an NDP MLA and former registered nurse, said on Twitter Kenney’s comments painted an “insulting picture” of frontline healthcare staff “putting their feet up between surgeries.”

Other health experts and advocates agree.

Sandra Azocar, Executive Director of Friends of Medicare Alberta said Kenney’s comments were “shameful” and “disrespectful.”

“Talking down to workers and professionals like he did in that video is definitely shameful and somewhat disrespectful,” Azocar told PressProgress.

Azocar disputes Kenney’s claims private surgeons perform twice as many surgeries as public surgeons in average work day.

“I would love to know where he actually got those numbers,” she said. “In the public system, the number of surgeries per day varies in terms of how many people are available at the time.”

Dr. Matt Henschke, a family doctor in Calgary, tweeted that Kenney’s suggestion doctors are taking coffee breaks between each case is “lame.”

“Usually as the junior I’d be responding to pages, doing orders/starting consults/reviewing the next case,” he said.

“If I just hung out for 45 minutes I’d be yelled at.”

Kenney announced, last week, his plan to cut back on administrative costs in Alberta’s healthcare system if he wins this year’s election. However, the province already has the lowest healthcare administration costs in Canada.

The UCP leader also promised to introduce “competition” in the province’s healthcare system by increasing the amount of privately-delivered operations.

But experts say introducing more private providers in Alberta’s healthcare system will ultimately cost taxpayers more.

University of Alberta political science professor John Church told PressProgress  previous private sourcing initiatives didn’t provide better services, and left taxpayers on the hook for millions of dollars.

“During the 1990s, Calgary contracted out for major joint replacement surgery to the private sector after the capacity of the public sector (public hospitals) had been reduced as a result of cut backs,” he said.

“Fast forward to 2010, the company filed for bankruptcy and the government had to intervene to prop the company up while the delivery of services was transitioned from the private sector back to the public sector.”

“Bottom line,” Church continued, “the taxpayers picked up the tab (millions of dollars) for a private sector company that went bankrupt. The service provided was not of a better quality, it cost more money for taxpayers while it was being provided, and, taxpayers were left on the hook when the company went bankrupt.”

Azocar said the UCP leader’s comments are “meant to undermine our public healthcare system.”

“The concept of competition is being tossed around as if healthcare was a commodity that can be sold to the highest payer,” she said. “That undermines the importance of healthcare as an essential public service.”

“When we’re talking about private versus public healthcare, it’s a whole idea of allowing corporations to create two levels of healthcare,” she added.

One for those who can pay out of pocket and one for the rest of us.”

 

Invest in our work

We break news and shine a light on stories Canada’s major media outlets miss. But we need your help to keep making an impact.

Subscribe to our Friday Newsletter

Too busy to follow the daily news? Get the inside scoop on the entire week’s news sent to your email inbox every Friday at noon.

Invest in our work

We break news and shine a light on stories Canada’s major media outlets miss. But we need your help to keep making an impact.

wilkinson-struggle-rent
wilkinson-struggle-rent
Video

BC Liberal Leader Andrew Wilkinson Says Struggling to Pay Rent Can Be ‘Fun’ and ‘Enjoyable’

“I was a renter for 15 years ... It’s kind of a wacky time of life, but it can be really enjoyable”

February 28, 2019

BC Liberal leader Andrew Wilkinson thinks the BC NDP government is spending too much time “pandering to renters” when it’s “landlords” who are really struggling.

In a speech to the BC Legislature Wednesday, Wilkinson suggested the government take a glass half-full “attitude” towards British Columbians who struggle to pay rent.

“I was a renter for 15 years,” Wilkinson said. “I lived in a dozen different rentals.”

“It was challenging at times, but it was fun,” he told the Legislature.

“It’s kind of a wacky…