Jason Kenney Keeps Making Misleading and Irresponsible Statements About COVID-19
Jason Kenney goes into damage control mode after facing widespread criticism for statements downplaying seriousness of COVID-19
Alberta Premier Jason Kenney keeps making head-scratching statements about COVID-19 — and now he’s doubling-down.
After receiving widespread criticism for statements he made last week downplaying the seriousness of COVID-19, Kenney made an appearance on a local right-wing radio show to do some damage control work.
“There is a very, very close correlation between this disease and age,” Kenney told Global News radio host Danielle Smith, the former leader of the Wildrose Party, one of the precursors of Kenney’s United Conservative Party.
“We’re always told that policy should be based on evidence and data.” Kenney added. “I’m trying to, through the data and the facts, bring balance to the debate, to point out that we can safely reengage in economic and social activity that is critical to our livelihoods and our lives together.”
Kenney was referring to statements equating COVID-19 with the flu and suggesting those under the age of 82 have little to worry about.
Speaking in the Alberta Legislature last week, Kenney stressed most people who die of COVID-19 have already outlived Alberta’s average life expectancy:
“The average age of death from COVID in Alberta is 83, and I’ll remind the house that the average life expectancy in the province is 82.”
That statement prompted people from across party lines to criticize the so-called “pro-life Premier” for devaluing the lives of the elderly:
I haven’t seen my 93 year old grandmother in months because I’m trying to keep her safe during the pandemic.
Jason Kenney would like you to know that the average life expectancy is 82 in Alberta, so if she dies from COVID19 she already beat the odds anyways.#ableg #yeg #yyc pic.twitter.com/38rNDyl1qv
— Thomas Dang (@ThomasDangAB) May 28, 2020
.@jkenney says:“The average age of death from COVID in Alberta is 83, and I’ll remind the house that the average life expectancy in the province is 82”. So, Alberta seniors, if you managed to live to 82 your shelf life is over. You can die. #ableg https://t.co/CbT0ECR9oP
— Thomas A. Lukaszuk (@LukaszukAB) May 28, 2020
Premier @jkenney throwing seniors literally *under the bus*
“death from COVID in Alberta is 83, and I’ll remind the House that the average life expectancy in the province is 82”
Kenney begins to normalize #COVID19 as a risk mainly to the elderly https://t.co/y5Grk2C5Sb
— David Khan (@Dave_Khan) May 28, 2020
Life expectancy at birth is 82 years. Life expectancy at 83 is another eight years or so. https://t.co/yXl4A9a2vY
— Éric Grenier (@EricGrenierCBC) May 29, 2020
In fact, COVID-19 can cause severe health problems and serious side effects for otherwise young, healthy people, even if that does not ultimately result in death.
As the Calgary Herald later pointed out, local hospitals are still reporting a number of teenagers and young adults are also being admitted to hospitals and intensive care units:
“As of Thursday, seven Albertans between the ages of 10 and 19 have needed hospital admission for novel coronavirus, with two of them requiring admission to intensive care units. Nine Albertans between 20 and 29 ended up in hospital, with one needing hospital admission and one becoming one of the 143 Albertans to die of the respiratory virus to date.”
A recent study also found evidence most people who die of COVID-19 are dying one decade earlier than they would have otherwise, contradicting the idea that COVID-19 victims were living on borrowed time.
Despite this, Kenney also made a bizarre statement describing COVID-19 as an “influenza,” a type of virus also referred to as the flu that is completely different from COVID-19:
“We cannot continue indefinitely to impair the social and economic, as well as the mental health and physiological health of the broader population for potentially a year for an influenza that does not generally threaten life apart from the elderly, the immuno-compromised.”
Premier Jason Kenney is taking criticism for these comments – downplaying #COVID19 as “influenza” and challenging public health experts to focus their policy responses. #ableg #abpoli
Background here: https://t.co/poDz8Xis8T pic.twitter.com/lWQAX8Z3lT
— CBC Edmonton (@CBCEdmonton) May 28, 2020
When it was pointed out that an influenza is not the same thing as a coronivrus, Kenney replied: “In some respects, the two are analogous.”
Medical experts, as well as Alberta Health Services own website, explicitly say COVID-19 is not like Influenza. Experts have told media the comparison is incorrect, dangerous, and downplays the seriousness of the pandemic.
Premier Kenney has called COVID-19 an “influenza” that’s mainly an issue for the elderly.
Is there any validity to the premier’s comments?
Edmonton-based critical care specialist Dr. Raiyan Chowdhury responds:
More at https://t.co/uCQmGSHoEL#cdnpoli #covid19canada pic.twitter.com/4vM3xjHPrZ
— CTV Power Play (@CTV_PowerPlay) May 29, 2020
“COVID-19 causes severe disease in a higher percentage of cases than seasonal influenza,” The AHS’ website notes. “Estimates of mortality in COVID-19 cases depend on many things, but on average they range from about 1-2 deaths per 100 people infected.”
“By comparison, seasonal influenza is deadly in about one in every 1,000 who are infected.”
The premier also told the legislature Alberta’s population has a “very high level of immune resistance against an influenza of this nature.”
Epidemiologist point out that is also not true.
Our journalism is powered by readers like you.
We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.
Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.