thumb-2020-03-02
thumb-2020-03-02
Analysis This article is more than 5 months old

How Saskatchewan’s ‘Wild West’ Campaign Finance Laws Help Wealthy Elites Prop Up Scott Moe’s Sask Party

Here are three reasons why Saskatchewan is being described as the "Wild West" of campaign finance laws

March 5, 2020

Is Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe banking on big money to help him win the next provincial election?

As Moe searches for excuses to call an early election, his party is also currently soliciting big donations from Saskatchewan’s wealthy elites through a program called the “Victory 2020 Fund.”

The fund is apparently aimed at high-end donors who can spare $1,000 or more per year to help the governing Saskatchewan Party with “election readiness” and to “ensure Saskatchewan voters get to know our leader, Premier Scott Moe.”

The fund’s website also includes laurels made of wheat husks and an image of Moe glowing like he just hit the jackpot at Caesar’s Palace.

Saskatchewan Party

Saskatchewan has been called the “Wild West” of campaign finance laws.

In fact, the province’s rules allowing unlimited donations from high-end individuals and corporations — regardless of whether they actually located in Saskatchewan — is one of the reasons Moe’s big business-friendly Sask Party has managed to hold on to power for over a decade.

Here are three things you ought to know about Saskatchewan’s “Wild West” campaign finance system:

Saskatchewan allows unlimited individual and corporate donations

As one of only two provinces without donation limits, Saskatchewan has been called the “wild west” of campaign finance.

“There are no donation limits on contributions to registered political parties or candidates,” states Elections Saskatchewan.

According Elections Saskatchewan records, in 2018 alone Moe’s party received $749,385 donations from 868 corporate entities — nearly 22 times higher than the opposition Saskatchewan NDP.

Campaign finance laws in the province are so loose, the Sask Party has actually managed to accept tens of thousands of dollars from registered charities, crown corporations, post-secondary institutions, public school boards and health regions as well as even local municipalities.

Wealthy Albertans have funnelled money to the Saskatchewan Party

In addition to unlimited donations, Elections Saskatchewan notes “donations can be accepted from Canadian citizens regardless of where they reside.”

A 2016 report by Progress Alberta report found the governing Sask Party had received more than $3 million in out-of-province donations from Alberta covering the decade between 2006 and 2016, including over $2 million in corporate donations from companies in Alberta.

Last year alone, donation records show that one-in-five corporate donations to the Sask Party came from out-of-province.

Unlimited donations could create the appearance of conflicts of interest

Saskatchewan’s lack of donation limits have raised questions about conflicting interests, as well as accusations that the governing party is using party donations to run pay-to-play schemes.

Last year, CBC News reported that Brandt Developments, a top Sask Party donor,  was able to submit plans to redevelop Wascana Park in Regina before the bidding process even began. The Brandt group of companies has donated $74,660 to the Sask Party over the years, and received nearly $4 million in government contracts.

Saskatchewan NDP leader Ryan Meili has also raised questions about SNC Lavalin’s donations to the governing Sask Party at the same time as the Saskatchewan government awarded SNC Lavalin $765 million in public contracts.

A 2012 report by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives on corporate influence in Saskatchewan argues that corporations rarely donate to a governing party out of the goodness of their heart — they’re usually expecting something in return.

“Business corporations are licensed by law to conduct particular enterprises for the benefit of their investors,” noted the CCPA.

“The only legal reason for their executives to give away the shareholders’ money is that the gift will advance their business.”

 


 

Correction: This story initially indicated Saskatchewan is one of three provinces that still allow unlimited corporate donations. In fact, only two provinces still allow unlimited corporate donations. While Newfoundland still allows unlimited corporate donations, PEI banned the practice in 2018.

WE'RE PROTECTING CANADIANS BY HOLDING THE POWERFUL ACCOUNTABLE

Journalism is an important public service. That’s why we’re prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable.

thumb-2020-03-03
thumb-2020-03-03
Fact-Check

‘Bait and Switch’: Doug Ford’s New Numbers On Special Education Staff Funding Are Not Adding Up

Education Minister Stephen Lecce claims special education will be fully-funded. Support staff workers say his numbers don’t add up.

March 4, 2020

Doug Ford’s government would have Ontarians believe it is making concessions on funding for special education support to secure a deal — but those involved in negotiations say the Ford government’s math doesn’t add up.

On Tuesday, Education Minister Stephen Lecce announced the government would make concessions to help strike a deal with Ontario teachers by lowering its class sizes and allowing parents to opt-out of mandatory eLearning.

Lecce also pledged $148 million to cover the…