Erin O’Toole’s Plan For Gig Workers Was ‘Carbon Copied’ From Uber’s Corporate Lobbyists

Gig workers warn the Conservative leader’s plan would erode employment standards and create a permanent underclass of precarious workers

One of Conservative leader Erin O’Toole’s platform proposals to help gig workers is identical to demands from Uber’s corporate lobbyists that would undermine Canadian employment standards, gig workers say.

“The Conservative platform is clearly a carbon copy of Uber’s Flexible Work+,” Jennifer Scott, president of Gig Workers United told PressProgress, adding that O’Toole’s platform would “create a third category of worker.”

O’Toole’s platform promises that a Conservative government would require app-based companies like Uber, Lyft and Skip the Dishes to make contributions to an Employee Savings Account every time they pay workers. Workers would be able to withdraw from these funds “as needed.”

What O’Toole doesn’t mention is that his proposal aligns with Uber’s recent lobbying to change provincial labour laws around worker classification. Uber falsely told Canadians it cannot offer workers benefits without changes to Employment Standards and worker classification policies.

Last year, Uber poured $220 million into a successful ballot campaign to pass Prop 22 in California, blitzing airwaves with messages labour leaders said “deceived the public” in order to permanently classify gig workers as “independent contractors” and exclude them from basic employment standards.

Last week, California’s top court ruled those changes were unconstitutional under US law.

Earlier this year, O’Toole brought Dan Mader on board as his director of policy — Mader was a corporate lobbyist for Uber and played a lead role developing the Conservative Party’s 2021 platform.

Toronto Star, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying of Canada

Scott, who also works as a courier for multiple app-based employers, says O’Toole’s proposal will not help workers but instead set a “frightening precedent.”

“It is cynical, disgusting, and offensive to see O’Toole speaking for big business instead of working class people,” Scott said. “In Canada, the working class is struggling – most of us are exhausted, angry, and fed up.”

Scott said O’Toole is “taking lessons from Uber” to present a misleading plan for Canadian workers.

“Portable benefits is the carrot Uber and other apps dangle in front of gig workers in exchange for permanently misclassifying us,” Scott added, noting gig workers have presented their own demands, which have been ignored by O’Toole. “Gig Workers don’t want to be used as props in a corporate and political game of hiding regressive policy actions behind seemingly progressive words.”

Joshua Mandryk, a labour lawyer with Goldblatt Partners, agrees that the Conservative’s policy proposal is “strikingly similar to the proposals for which Uber has been lobbying.”

“The Conservative proposal correctly acknowledges the problem with the status quo, but proposes the entirely wrong solution by carving gig workers out of our public EI and CPP systems and locking them into a second-tier scheme,” Mandryk told PressProgress.

“While framed as a measure to support gig workers, this proposal must be understood as a carve-out that would deny misclassified gig workers the basic workplace rights they deserve,” Mandryk explained.

“The only fair future for gig workers starts with employment status and a strong floor of workplace rights.”

Mandryk says a better method to protect gig workers would be to enshrine the “ABC test” in labour law, which would make it more difficult for employers to misclassify workers as independent contractors instead of employees.

Bea Bruske, President of the Canadian Labour Congress, calls O’Toole’s strategy “cynical” and said “Erin O’Toole’s gig economy policies read like they were run off of an Uber mimeograph machine.”

“For too long, Uber has dictated the terms of workers’ employment and offloaded operating costs on drivers,” Bruske told PressProgress. “They haven’t been held accountable for providing basic employment standards, like a minimum wage and vacation pay. Misclassifying these workers as independent contractors means these workers are excluded from unemployment benefits and even basic labour standards protection.”

“Nothing O’Toole is proposing will change any of this,” Bruske said.

“Instead of backing precarious workers, O’Toole is standing with the giant app companies.”


Help us protect Canadians by holding the powerful accountable.

Journalism is an important public service. That’s why PressProgress is prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable during the coronavirus pandemic.

Please consider supporting our award-winning non-profit news organization so we can keep making a positive impact for Canadians.


Support Our Journalism
PressProgress is an award-winning non-profit news organization focused on uncovering and unpacking the news through original investigative and explanatory journalism.

Most Shared

thumb-2021-09-029 Explainer

Erin O’Toole’s Plan to ‘Secure Pensions’ Could Allow Companies to Cut Pensions, Labour Experts Say

Related Stories


Here’s What Canada’s 3 Major Parties’ Climate Platforms Mean for Workers

View the post

Here’s What Canada’s 3 Major Parties Say They Will Do For Workers and Labour Unions

View the post

Erin O’Toole’s Plan to ‘Secure Pensions’ Could Allow Companies to Cut Pensions, Labour Experts Say

View the post


Work & rights

Shanice Regis-Wilkins

How Labour Activists Pushed For Policies That Protect Workers and the Environment This Election

View the post
Equity & Politics

Erica Ifill

Why Justin Trudeau’s Strategy on Affordable Housing Isn’t Working

View the post
Human rights & inclusion

Amira Elghawaby

Why Immigrant, Newcomer and Racialized Communities Still Face Barriers to Voting in Canada

View the post