Are Conservatives race-baiting Facebook with this First Nations petition?
What kind of reaction did they expect? A recent posting on the Conservative Party of Canada’s Facebook page has managed to bring out the worst in their supporters by playing to the worst stereotypes about First Nations. Inspiring user comments like “they have too many rights” and “tear up all treaties,” the post asks people […]
What kind of reaction did they expect?
A recent posting on the Conservative Party of Canada’s Facebook page has managed to bring out the worst in their supporters by playing to the worst stereotypes about First Nations.
Inspiring user comments like “they have too many rights” and “tear up all treaties,” the post asks people to add their names to a petition by supporting “more transparency for First Nations governments”:
The post links to a message from Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Minister Bernard Valcourt, promoting the Conservatives’ controversial First Nations Transparency Act — which has been criticized by academics and the Assembly of First Nations alike as perpetuating “the myth of the crooked Indian” and as being part of a strategy aimed at “controlling and containing” First Nations communities.
Valcourt’s message to Conservative supporters claims they are “getting results” — pointing to revelations about the compensation of two First Nations chiefs as evidence. Valcourt adds:
“Our new law is helping deliver more effective, transparent and accountable governments. All chiefs and councils will now be responsible to their band members. First Nation communities will be stronger, more self-sufficient and more prosperous as a result.”
And although Valcourt leaves supporters with the impression that corruption ran rampant in First Nations communities managed by irresponsible chiefs and councils, a Toronto Star editorial this week points out that if the newly disclosed data proves anything, “it’s to correct an unfair public perception that most aboriginal leaders are highly overpaid.”
In fact, when the Star looked at the data, they discovered median compensation for chiefs was only $60,000, while many chiefs and band leaders either took no salary or very minimal compensation (less than $10,000).
Valcourt suggests the Conservatives’ law will transform First Nations communities, making them “stronger” where they were weak, “self-sufficient” where they were dependent and “prosperous” where they were impoverished.
But Valcourt’s petition offers no comment on the many inequality issues facing First Nations communities:
- A new report highlights the major gaps in access to health care and social services for aboriginal children.
- Another recent report outlined the “pervasive” racism facing aboriginals within the health care system.
- The median income for aboriginals is significantly lower than the rest of Canadians.
- Aboriginal children are disproportionately represented in foster care.
- Education gap: Aboriginal students suffer from higher levels of poverty and a significantly higher dropout rate (60% of aboriginal students on reserve and 43% off reserve, compared to just 9% of the rest of Canadian students)
And what message did Conservative supporters take away from the petition?
You be the judge:
UPDATE: Since this post was published, the Conservatives have refused to reveal how many signatures their petition has garnered. APTN reports that, earlier this week, the government was forced to pull a photo initially used to promote the petition that featured Assembly of First Nations National Chief Perry Bellegarde.
Photo: pmwebphotos. Used under Creative Commons License.
Help us protect Canadians by holding the powerful accountable.
Journalism is an important public service. That’s why PressProgress is prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable during the coronavirus pandemic.
Please consider supporting our award-winning non-profit news organization so we can keep making a positive impact for Canadians.
Support Our Journalism