Analysis This article is more than 2 years old

The Government Stripped Postal Workers of Their Constitutional Rights. Now Protests Are Breaking Out Across Canada.

The Liberal government’s anti-labour back-to-work legislation is sparking nationwide protests

December 1, 2018

Canada’s postal workers are dialing up the pressure after the Liberal government in Ottawa passed back-to-work legislation widely seen as unconstitutional.

Following a month of rotating strikes at Canada Post facilities aimed at drawing attention to heavy workloads and unsafe work conditions, the Liberal government passed heavy-handed back-to-work legislation this week with the support of Andrew Scheer’s Conservatives.

Labour Minister Patricia Hajdu shrugged off concerns that the legislation violates the constitutional rights of postal workers, citing the “economic harm” a labour disruption could have on “businesses” and “international commerce” during the “busy retail season.”

Critics accuse the Liberals of siding with big multinational online retailers like Amazon over the rights and freedoms of Canadian postal workers.

Now the Canadian Union of Postal Workers, which represents Canada Post workers, says it’s responding by launching a nationwide pressure campaign.

“All options remain on the table” CUPW president Mike Palecek said in a statement, reiterating the need to “address health and safety, equitable treatment, fair wages and working conditions and the democratic right to free collective bargaining.”

Rallies are being organized across Canada this weekend to show support for the rights and freedoms of postal workers.

Meanwhile, postal workers and their allies are participating in acts of “non-violent civil disobedience” by staging protests at Canada Post facilities and the offices of Liberal MPs, including Finance Minister Bill Morneau and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

Here are three big things Canadians should know about the labour dispute:

The back-to-work legislation likely violates Charter-protected freedoms

To justify back-to-work legislation, Canada Post management embellished claims  that it was experiencing a backlog in parcels while the labour minister claimed she spoke with a disabled homeless man who wasn’t receiving social assistance cheques (Hajdu’s staff later admitted she never spoke to a disabled homeless man).

Now, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association is calling the Liberals’ anti-worker legislation “a serious threat to workers’ constitutional rights” and the union is vowing to fight the legislation in court.

Similar anti-labour back-to-work legislation introduced by the Harper government in 2011 was later ruled unconstitutional by the Ontario Superior Court in 2016.

Labour lawyer Paul Cavalluzzo, who argued the case, wrote that Harper’s legislation violated freedom of expression and freedom of association, and “not demonstrably justified in a free and democratic country.”

Two legal experts recently told the Canadian Press that though the new legislation is carefully worded to avoid some of the legal problems with Harper’s bill, there is a “very open and real” possibility it will be struck down as unconstitutional too.

According to Cavalluzzo, the government’s interference in collective bargaining was really about giving Canada Post management the upper-hand to force the union into accepting a weaker deal:

“Whereas the Union was forced to make significant concessions in an effort to reach an agreement and avoid the punitive legislation, the Corporation was able to escalate its demands and seek even greater concessions than it had in the months of negotiations preceding the legislation.”

Postal workers are fighting for safer working conditions

One of the central issues in the labour dispute relates to postal workers being overburdened with heavy workloads, undermining workplace safety.

Postal workers currently experience high on-the-job injury rates and the Liberals’ strikebreaking legislation denies the union the ability to negotiate health and safety measures.

Union representatives have reported the following injury statistics:

  • Out of 50,000 employees there have been 30,877 injuries in the last four years.
  • Nearly half of those injuries (14,752) were classified as disabling.
  • 25% of letter carriers were injured on the job in 2017. Across the company, one in 12 employees experienced an on the job injury that year.
  • Disabling injuries for rural service mail carriers climbed 30% over the last three years.

Postal workers are demanding the creation of more full time positions to alleviate the current burden of meeting increasing demand on employees.

Meanwhile, there exists a growing wage gap between urban and rural employees. Rural carriers, according to the union, earn 25 per cent less than their urban counterparts for the same work.

And many rural mail carriers are women, something that contributes to gender pay inequity at Canada Post.

Yet Canada Post is consistently profitable

Between 2014 and 2017, Canada Post reported profits totaling nearly $400 million.

That may come as some surprise considering many right-wing anti-labour groups have suggested Canada Post has become obsolete in the 21st century thanks to the Internet.

In fact, the opposite is true. This spring, the crown corporation said it is seeing “unprecedented growth in its parcels business” thanks to “the important role Canada Post plays delivering for online shoppers and retailers across the country.”

According to Canada Post’s own numbers,  parcel delivery now accounts for one-third of its revenues, increasing by a staggering 20% between 2017 and 2018, with industry observers predicting even bigger growth in the future.



Journalism is an important public service. That’s why we’re prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable.


BC Liberal MLA: LGBTQ Anti-Bullying Program Could Cause ‘Mental Health Issues’ for School Children

BC Liberal MLA Laurie Throness warns SOGI 123 anti-bullying initiative encourages ‘self-harm’, compares gender to a plant

November 30, 2018

One of Andrew Wilkinson’s BC Liberal MLAs says he worries an initiative aimed at protecting LGBTQ students from bullying will scar school children for life.

Laurie Throness, the BC Liberal MLA for Chilliwack-Kent, told the BC Legislature this week that the province’s SOGI 123 program, an anti-bullying initiative designed to promote safe and inclusive school environments, may leave school children with  “mental health issues” and other “long-term unintended consequences.”

Although he stressed “no child should be bullied,”…