Lorne Park
Lorne Park This article is more than 11 months old
ANALYSIS

Ontario’s Government Claims the Province Isn’t Privatizing Water. Experts Are Not Convinced.

“The way that this act is written creates this slippery slope towards privatization”

The Ontario government is pushing back on claims that it is trying to privatize water, but experts and advocates are saying the province’s explanation fails to ease concerns about its plans.

At a press conference at the Lorne Park Water Treatment Plant in Mississauga on Nov. 14, Ontario NDP leader Marit Stiles gave a statement accusing Doug Ford’s Progressive Conservatives of attempting to restructure water delivery by moving to a private, for-profit model.

Through Bill 60, the Fighting Delays, Building Faster Act, the provincial government is proposing a restructuring of water and wastewater service delivery that would allow it to designate a corporation to provide water and sewage services to lower-tier municipalities that meet specific requirements. These corporations would not be crown corporations or administrative units of the province.

Currently, water and wastewater treatment are handled by municipal and regional governments, with some communities contracting out operations to third parties like the Ontario Clean Water Agency.

The bill is expected to pass as early as today.

The Toronto Star covered Stiles’ press conference, but later issued a correction after the government clarified that the bill is “not a water privatization proposal.” 

However, Simon Enoch, senior researcher at the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, says the language in the bill about these corporations is vague. 

“They’re really trading on the confusion or sort of opaqueness of what a public corporation is,” Enoch told PressProgress. “A ‘public corporation’ also just means a corporation that’s publicly-traded, which is privately-owned.”

The legislation makes no mention of these new organizations being publicly owned, but it is stated that they will incorporate under the Business Corporations Act, which is used to incorporate for-profit, private corporations.

Alexandra Pinosa, a researcher at CUPE, told PressProgress that Bill 60 and changes to the Municipal Act set the stage to replace current water-delivery services provided by regional municipalities with a for-profit entity at the direction of the minister, starting with Peel Region.

“Water is the last public utility in the province — electricity and gas have already been privatized,” Pinosa said. “Previous bills under Ford’s government plan to replicate this for-profit utility model for water in six other regional municipalities: York, Halton, Waterloo, Niagara, Durham, and the County of Simcoe.”

Krista Laing, CUPE Ontario’s municipal workers chair, said in a statement, “We see the risks, and we’re calling out this gaslighting for what it is — an attempt to weaken public oversight and hand critical services to private interests.”

Pinosa added that the Peel Region Transition Board has not released any recommendations, forecasts, research or financial documents regarding this transition to the public.

Rebecca Kolarich from Environmental Defence told PressProgress that Bill 60 could lead to privatization even if this isn’t the goal of the current government.

“If passed, this would give the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing the power to make municipalities give water and wastewater infrastructure to corporations,” Kolarich said.

“It may not be their intention as of right now to privatize water, but the way that this act is written creates this slippery slope towards privatization, making water a for-profit service due to the fact that the public corporation in this legislation states that it must be incorporated under this Business Corporations Act,” Kolarich added.

Matthew Manassis is a water operator in training and VP of CUPE Local 241, which represents Guelph municipal workers. Manassis told PressProgress that it doesn’t make sense to change the way these services are provided. 

“I work on a system that has really dedicated public workers, who know their system really well and maintain an amazingly efficient system that’s really resilient and prepared for emergencies,” Manassis said.

Manassis said that as things stand, the way water services are provided is working already, and the water provided to residents in Guelph is “world-class.”

“I’ve been in this system for two years, and the onboarding and the training we receive and the licensing requirements are very stringent, and really underline the importance of the work we do and the history behind why water is regulated the way it is in Ontario,” Manassis said.

Enoch said that this bill seems to be making a new species of corporation that looks like it can be publicly owned but has no protections to ensure it will stay that way. He added that there were already vehicles that could have been used in place of for-profit corporations, like a municipal services corporation.

A municipal services corporation is a municipally-owned corporation that can provide services, like water, wastewater or broadband. According to the Association of Municipalities of Ontario, a municipal services corporation cannot issue any private shares, and municipalities remain the sole shareholders. 

Enoch said there might have been specific reasons the province didn’t use municipal services corporations, including the fact they require public input. 

“This isn’t their first rodeo, you can be precise in legislation,” Enoch said. “The fact that they aren’t being precise over what these sort of so-called public corporations are going to be, I think should really set off alarm bells in people in Ontario’s heads.” 

Municipalities across the world have used private models of delivery for water and wastewater, but Kolarich said that many of these municipalities eventually returned to a public model.

“Since the early 2000s, there have been hundreds of worldwide cases of water re-municipalization,” said Kolarich. “That’s the process that brings water back under public control from being private, and this was in response to the failure of water privatization.”

Manassis said that the Walkerton water disaster was brought up in training as an example of what could happen if water is privatized.

“There are plenty of examples from around Canada and around the world that show that privatizing water doesn’t work, it’s dangerous and it’s expensive,” Mannassis said. “We’ve seen what can go wrong when the province tries to privatize critical potential public services like water.”

Hamilton privatized its water in the 90s, and the results were disastrous. Less than a year after a private company took over, massive sewage leaks and backups occurred, dumping nearly 200 million litres of untreated human waste, heavy metals and chemicals into Hamilton Harbour. Over 100 homes were filled with raw sewage from backups.

Beyond the safety concerns with privatization, Manassis said it’s less efficient and more expensive than a public service. 

“You pay more because now you have to pay for profits on top of the public service,” Manassis added. “Two dollars a cubic meter for pure, clean, world-class drinking water is an incredible deal.”

These new corporations for water services follow a pattern from the province, increasing the government’s involvement in portfolios it did not previously have control over. Earlier this month, the province announced the creation of new offices in public education that, according to advocates, look like an attempt to replace school board trustees. 

PressProgress reached out to the provincial government for comment, but did not receive a response.

 

Our journalism is powered by readers like you.

We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.

Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.

 

Become a member
Eric Wickham
Ontario Reporter
Eric Wickham is PressProgress' Ontario reporter. His reporting focuses on housing, food security and education.

Most Shared

OBSCU2 NEWS

Why the Flight Attendants’ Strike Was 'A Perfect Storm' for Labour

Related Stories

ANALYSIS

‘Resurgence’ of racism and xenophobia in Canada’s policies a result of ‘growing and systemic racial hatred,’ experts say

View the post
ANALYSIS

How did the BC Conservatives turn Surrey blue?

View the post
ANALYSIS

Some BC residents wait five years to get connected with a doctor, here’s how politicians plan to change that

View the post
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.