portage protest1
portage protest1 This article is more than 2 months old
NEWS

Sold a Lie: Emails Reveal Government and College Assured International Students they Would be Eligible for a Post-Graduation Work Permit Despite Rule Changes.

Now, students are facing removal orders from Canada after an ICE-like CBSA raid at their protest in Calgary

International students protesting sudden rule changes and a mass refusal of work permits in Alberta faced an ICE-like immigration raid at a peaceful protest in Calgary last week.

1500 students from Portage College, an Alberta-based public college with partner campuses in Edmonton and Calgary, say that they became suddenly without status after their work permits were refused after graduation. They say this happened despite following the appropriate pathways and previous assurances that they would be eligible for the permit.

Image credit: khaira_teji/Instagram

Based on the eligibility rules that existed at the time, the students had no reason to believe their post-graduation work permits (PGWP) applications would be refused. In June of this year, the IRCC quietly changed the rules, without a formal announcement, stating that students who complete a “non-credit program of study (except for a flight school program)” are not eligible for a PGWP.

However, many of these students who lost their status started their programs before the rules changed. 

Why are students protesting?

When there were potential murmurs that the government may be making changes, one student, who has asked not be named, checked in with their college, to ensure they were not wasting thousands of dollars on tuition fees for a program only to have the goal posts moved at the last minute.

Documents obtained by PressProgress show that the Canadian Institute of Osteopathic Therapy (CIOT) Calgary, which has a partner program with Portage College, assured the student in September of 2024 that they would still be eligible for a work permit upon graduating–guidance they said they received from the government directly.

In the document, Student Services told the student that “This change may not impact your eligibility for a PGWP.”

Letter from the college to the student in September of 2024

The attached message the college received when seeking clarification from the government said:

“Currently enrolled students will not be affected in terms of their eligibility for the PGWP (they are grandfathered).”

The school’s representative then told the student “not to panic.”

“We urge you not to panic and to focus on your studies and completing your program as per your enrollment.”

In July, hundreds of students received refusal letters stating that their “non credit” programs made them ineligible for a work permit, leaving them vulnerable and without status despite following the appropriate pathway. 

Novjot Salaria, a former international student and member of the Naujawan Support Network–an advocacy organization supporting international students across the country, says that it’s important to remember that the students who now find themselves in this predicament were following the rules and a legal pathway for immigration in Canada. 

Image credit: khaira_teji/Instagram

“You come here as a student and then you become eligible for post-graduation work permit and after that you attain experience in a certain category, and then you become eligible for one or another permanent residency pathways,” Salaria told PressProgress.

“That’s the pathway given by the Government of Canada and there is no rule breaking happening, it’s not something that the government owes you–it’s something that has to be earned.”

Students have been protesting the refusals in both Edmonton and Calgary since July, saying that they were sold a lie.

CBSA Raid at Calgary Protest

Last week in Calgary, students say police arrived asking them to move their tents, which they set up the night before due to the rain.

Manraj, whose name has been changed to protect his identity, said he received a call from a friend, asking for help moving their supplies.

“CBSA showed up and started asking for identification. We thought we were all safe because of the 90-day restoration period,” Manraj told PressProgress.

The 90-day restoration period is a window in which to apply to regain status. Students must stay in Canada and are unable to work or study until they regain status.

“We went for an interview and they gave us an exclusion order right away,” Manraj said.  

About a dozen students received “exclusion orders,” from the CBSA, meaning they must “leave Canada immediately, confirm departure with the CBSA and cannot return to Canada for one year.”

An excerpt of the exclusion order received by “Manraj”

When addressing why CBSA attended the peaceful protest, according to a statement from a CBSA spokesperson, the agency “receives information from various sources, including referrals from law enforcement agencies, who contact the CBSA in cases where a person’s legal status in Canada is unclear or when there is an existing immigration warrant against an individual.”

On August 12, CBSA attended the protest after Calgary Police requested a “status check” on four individuals at the protest.

“Upon confirmation that two of those individuals were not in compliance with their immigration status, CBSA officers attended Saddletown Circle NE and conducted further investigation, including status checks to identify additional persons of potential interest for non-compliance under IRPA,” Rebecca Purdy, senior spokesperson for CBSA told PressProgress.

“In total, 20 individuals had their status verified, with 12 individuals identified as being possibly inadmissible under IRPA. The individuals were asked to attend the CBSA office later that day for a follow-up interview.

Students also had to forfeit their passports to the CBSA.

Photo of  heavy police presence at the Calgary protest

Manraj, who began his program in January of 2024, said he too was under the impression that his program would be eligible for a PGWP upon completion.

“When we found out about the “non-credit” term everybody was concerned. We were ready to leave the college at that point because nobody just wanted to waste money there. But we confirmed everything by email by the college itself,” Manraj said.

“We are not even asking for special treatment. This is our initial PGWP. Everybody gets it. Why is it different in our case?”

Salaria says there are many misconceptions about the protests.

“These students are protesting for the PGWP work permit, which they were eligible for when they enrolled to the colleges, and they paid fees like $40,000 to $50,000 to get that eligibility.”

Manraj said he and the others in the same circumstance are trying to raise funds for a judicial review, but are facing astronomical costs which are complicated by the fact that they are unable to work. 

“We were not prepared for such a thing to happen. So right now our bank accounts are run empty,” he added.

“For the last 10 days, we are meeting with all the lawyers we possibly can, and most of the lawyers said ‘we don’t even have an idea of what happened, how that happened, and how to approach the problem.”

Students impacted by the exclusion orders are able to file a judicial review against the exclusion orders, but the costs of a review could be upwards of $100,000. 

They have recently started a GoFundMe to help raise legal funds.

Parmbir Gill, a Toronto lawyer who is a part of the Naujawan Support Network, says that the CBSA’s raid on the protest raises more questions, given that the right to protest is enshrined in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, not just for citizens, but for everyone.

“The constitutional right to protest that is enshrined in Section Two (of the Charter) belongs to ‘everyone’ in Canada, not just citizens. The students in Calgary were exercising that right when the CBSA conducted its raid. That makes the raid unprecedented, certainly in relation to previous international student protests which were at least tacitly recognized as off limits,” Gill told PressProgress.

“Why the CBSA did nothing for a month and then finally took action, that’s unclear. What is clear is that the action represents an escalation that will increase hostility and attacks against immigrants across the country,”

Gill said that the CBSA’s raid demonstrates an attack on the right to peacefully assemble–a right held by international students and migrants.

“They have just as much of a right to express themselves politically, to peacefully assemble, to demonstrate against the government as anyone else. Students, migrants, undocumented migrants are on the same plane as citizens with respect to that right,” Gill said.

He adds that the rhetoric around students has been increasingly hostile due to a rise in hate against immigrants.

“The online rhetoric around international students goes beyond mere criticism of this or that protest. It denigrates these people as if they’re something less than human, as if they, do not have rights under the Constitution of this country, which is plainly false,” Gill said.

Salaria agreed that the CBSA raid and the overall lack of empathy towards the protesters come against the backdrop of rising anti-immigrant and international student sentiment in Canada. 

“There is already a scapegoating or a kind of narrative that international students are responsible for housing prices or the job market, or grocery prices, which is all basically plain lies because international students don’t build the houses. We don’t manage the grocery prices,” Salaria said. 

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith recently spoke out when asked about the protests, telling students to “go home,” if they did not receive a permanent residency.


Salaria says that Smith explicitly telling students, who followed the correct immigration pathways, to “go home” fuels a narrative that already exists about international students and immigrants. 

“We have been hearing this as a kind of slur for racialized people for many instances in history,” Salaria said. “Whenever there is racism or there is some kind of scapegoating or narrative in society, racialized people would always be told to ‘go back to your country.’” 

“She’s using the (similar) phrase, which further fuels the scapegoating of international students.”

The IRCC did not respond to PressProgress’ multiple requests for comment prior to publication.

Update: Days after the publication of this story, an IRCC spokesperson provided the following statement to PressProgress, regarding changes to the PGWP program:

“In 2024, the PGWP program underwent several reforms with the goal of better aligning the program to labour market needs. These reforms included removing eligibility for curriculum-licensed agreements, introducing a language requirement for most applicants, and introducing a field of study requirement for non-degree applicants.”

In Fall 2024, we communicated these reform changes to National Education Associations, Designated Learning Institutions and on our website. These changes did not impact other existing PGWP eligibility requirements.

The “grandfathering” referenced in the correspondence provided relates specifically to the field of study requirement introduced in November 2024. Students who were already enrolled before November 1, 2024, were exempt from meeting that requirement. This did not exempt applicants from other existing PGWP eligibility requirements.

In June 2026, the update to the PGWP webpage clarified guidance on existing requirements and how they apply to non-credit programs of study. This was done in response to client and stakeholder feedback and did not introduce a new eligibility requirement. The department continuously reviews and updates its guidance and online content in response to feedback from clients and stakeholders.”

Our journalism is powered by readers like you.

We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.

Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.

 

Become a member
Rumneek Johal
Executive Editor
Rumneek Johal is Executive Editor at PressProgress, whose reporting focuses on British Columbia, systemic inequality, workers and communities, as well as on racism and far-right extremism.

Most Shared

OBSCU2 NEWS

Why the Flight Attendants’ Strike Was 'A Perfect Storm' for Labour

Related Stories

NEWS

Ontario School Board Council of Unions votes 94% in favour of strike

View the post
NEWS

Pediatric patients with complex chronic illnesses impacted by BC’s quiet changes to virtual care

View the post
NEWS

Lawsuit alleges top executive hired to address sexual harassment in BC paramedicine terminated while on maternity leave

View the post
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.