Federal Government Steps in to Stop Controversial Billy Bishop Expansion After Overwhelming Opposition from Toronto Residents
The province’s plans were one of many unilateral changes made by the Ford government within the city.
In their win against Doug Ford’s controversial airport expansion plans, residents of Toronto may have found a way to stop Doug Ford’s unilateral changes to their city: the federal government.
On Friday night it was announced that the federal government would not be supporting premier Doug Ford’s controversial plans to expand Billy Bishop airport.
Through an online survey of over 87,000 respondents conducted by the federal government, Toronto residents made it clear that they did not want this airport. Of the respondents, 87% stated they were opposed to the airport expansion plans.
“It sounds like the federal government heard loud and clear from the community, and this is their decision to end jets now,” Norm Di Pasquale, program manager of No Jets TO told PressProgress. “It’s a triumph for our community power and democratic participation.”
The city of Toronto has opposed these expansion plans, but was shut out of the conversation when the province took over the city’s share of a tripartite agreement and expropriated a parcel of land around the airport through Bill 110, the Building Billy Bishop Airport Act.
The provincial government’s plan to expand the airport would double its capacity, extend the runway to nearly two kilometres long and allow Boeing 737s to land downtown. Critics voiced their concern about the environmental impact, an increase in traffic and the health and quality of life problems from emissions that the airport expansion would bring.
“We’re talking about Boeing 737 jets landing every two and a half minutes at the island airport,” Di Pasquale said. “98,000 homes would be impacted, including mechanically sealing windows, removing balconies, losing storage from buildings, negatively impacting affordable housing and housing values.”
“We’ve spent billions on revitalizing our waterfront, all three levels of government, and it’s given us billions more back,” Di Pasquale said. “Why put all of that at risk for jets which really don’t add any discernable value?”
Di Pasquale said the federal government still had two votes in the matter through Transport Canada and the Toronto Port Authority, which prevented the province from amending the tripartite agreement governing Billy Bishop airport.
“If any signatory of the three says, we’re not open to an amended tripartite agreement, the tripartite agreement does not get amended,” he said.
Di Pasquale said that it is heartening that the federal government listened to what the people most affected by this proposal actually wanted.
Doug Ford’s embattled Ontario government has involved itself in several fights in the city during its tenure. It shut down Ontario Place and the Ontario Science Centre, it used the notwithstanding clause to change the size of city council, and has threatened to use it again to rip out bike lanes in the city.
Last week, a poll reported that Doug Ford’s approval dropped to 24%, a new low for the Premier.
Di Pasquale says that other municipal fights that are happening between advocates in the city and the province could take some lessons from this victory.
“I would say it’s pretty clear to anybody who’s been involved in any of these fights that Doug Ford and his government do not listen,” he said. “So you have to try to find some other party that is involved that is interested in listening.”
“People power still matters, we may have to find different creative avenues for that people power, but it matters and can change elected leaders’ minds,” Di Pasquale said.
Di Pasquale has been involved in the fight against expanding Billy Bishop for over a decade. In 2015, there were debates about expanding the airport. This discussion was locally led, and eventually shut down.
According to Di Pasquale, the major difference between the discussion in 2015 and 2026 was Doug Ford’s efforts to shut the city out of the conversation around the airport.
“Premier Ford just tried to kind of steamroll his way through to this jet approval without consulting, and then when people did have an opportunity to have their say through this federal survey, they did in massive numbers,” he said.
According to Di Pasquale, this victory is an example of why people need to get involved in causes they care about, because when people come together collectively, they are able to have their voices heard.
“I learned a decade ago, last time this fight came up, that If you don’t fight for what you love, you’re going to lose it,” he said.
“There is a little something that each and every person can do, and if they do it, we will win.”
Our journalism is powered by readers like you.
We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.
Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.
Become a member
@ericwickham.ca