ombuds report - Khai Dong:Unsplash
ombuds report - Khai Dong:Unsplash This article is more than 11 months old
NEWS

‘Their Conditions Worsened in Hospital’: Ontario Ombudsman Report Details Inhumane Conditions, Prolonged Hospital Stays for Severely Disabled People

"Her health has been irreversibly damaged… I worry there isn’t much hope for her or our situation."

Ria hasn’t been able to see her severely disabled, nonverbal 12-year-old daughter, Arya, without child protective services present since April 2023. 

The single mom of two has requested to be anonymous, as there is an ongoing legal battle over her and her daughter’s rights. Their names have been changed in this article.

The forces preventing Ria from being with her daughter in the hospitals and group homes she is regularly shuffled between — staying at each for months at a time when the group home decides her needs are too complex for them to handle — involve Ontario’s Ministry of Health and Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services (MCCSS).

“For [my daughter’s] level of complexity, she fell completely under MCCSS’ purview as well as the Ministry of Health,” Ria told PressProgress. “Rather than it meaning she gets the full amount of services she needs from both, we fell through the cracks and she got almost nothing since birth, with each Ministry referring me to speak with the other.”

Arya’s story is not an isolated one.

The Ontario Ombudsman office’s latest investigation found there is a need for the health ministry and MCCSS to collaborate better, as dozens of people with complex needs and disabilities across Ontario have been languishing in hospitals, sometimes for years, due to a lack of adequate housing options. 

“This report highlights seven individuals who languished in hospitals, sometimes restrained for months or years, and they weren’t there for medical reasons, but because there was nowhere else for them to go,” said ombudsman Paul Dubé at a press conference on Tuesday.

“In case after case, their conditions worsened in hospital.”

That’s what happened to Arya. Her family had some access to home care services until 2016 when Ria needed to admit her to a group home while dealing with a domestic violence situation. 

During the months-long stretches that Ria’s daughter spent in hospital, first in London Health Sciences Centre then at McMaster Children’s Hospital, Ria said she did everything in her power to access home care services, even on a part-time basis, in order to care for Arya at home. 

But she was denied.

“The hospital was not safe for her,” she said, adding that Arya kept catching infections and developed bedsores that would not heal. 

“She had eight or nine aspiration pneumonias in two months,” referring to a type of lung infection that happens when saliva or stomach contents end up in the lungs and airway passages. It’s not a type of infection that Arya ever experienced while at home with her family. 

“She has very much declined from just that alone.”

‘Chemically, physically restrained for four years’

The ombudsman’s report was compiled based on 55 complaints from advocates, social workers and hospital staff who reported often inhumane conditions in which people with disabilities and complex care needs have been kept for prolonged periods of time. 

It features the horrifying stories of seven people who experienced extreme neglect and brutality while hospitalized for periods of 15 months to eight plus years. 

One man in his 30s was chemically and physically restrained for four years; another in his 50s lived in a hospital for eight years and finally moved to a home, only to die three months later; and a 22-year-old man was chemically sedated and tied to his bed for most of his two-year stay in hospital.

“They and their caregivers are navigating incredibly complex realities [like] autism, cerebral palsy, anxiety, obsessive compulsive disorders, schizophrenia, intellectual delays, seizure disorders, and a range of mental health and physical challenges,” Dubé said. 

“The fact that our system continues to rely on hospitals as a default placement is not just inefficient, it’s unfair, inappropriate, and profoundly harmful to them and their families.”

In Arya’s case, she was born with spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy that affects all four limbs; she has cortical visual impairment making her legally blind; dysphagia, meaning she can’t swallow on her own and needs tube feeding and her airways need to be cleared by suction; she has epilepsy and experiences status seizures, which are seizures that last for hours at a time; and a host of other complex needs. 

Much like the subjects in the ombudsman’s report, prolonged hospital stays, where units are understaffed and not equipped to provide the round-the-clock care Arya needs, made her conditions worse, Ria said. 

As a result of the report’s findings, the ombudsman called on Ontario’s health ministry and MCCSS to adopt a set of key recommendations that would ensure the departments work closer together.

They include establishing a joint planning forum, funding more supportive living options, strengthening recruitment and retention of healthcare workers including French-speaking staff, and improving data collection and disclosure.

According to the ombudsman, the two ministries have “unequivocally” accepted all of the recommendations and are required to update the ombudsman every six months about their progress on each point. 

This latest report comes after years of Ontario hospitals reporting budget deficits and chronic understaffing, and one month after the province announced a $1.1 billion investment over three years to extend home care services, in an effort to “reduce pressures” on hospitals and long-term care homes. 

The fight against reinstitutionalization 

Brad Evoy, Executive Director of the Disability Justice Network of Ontario, told PressProgress that stories of involuntary hospitalization like the ones included in the ombudsman’s report have severely impacted people in the disabled community. 

Evoy called these involuntary hospitalizations a fundamental violation of people’s rights to live good, autonomous lives. He added that this was part of a larger trend of rights being taken away from people with disabilities. 

“It’s all part of one continuum of reinstitutionalization, an area that we’re really concerned about,” said Evoy.

Deinstitutionalization refers to the move away from using long-term psychiatric facilities to provide care for people with disabilities that happened in the 1960s. The history of poor living conditions, neglect, and abuse in these institutions has been documented by researchers and disability advocates. Reinstitutionalization is the return to relying on large-scale institutions, or their practices, to provide care. 

“We talk about reinstitutionalization, this is all about the idea that these institutions are resurfacing with new faces and new guises over time,” Evoy said. 

According to Evoy, real solutions to the mistreatment of people with disabilities start with direct lines of funding for care, and a broader recognition of a full personhood for people with disabilities. 

“Ultimately, that takes kind of a mindset shift to fully see disabled people as people, and to fully engage with our community as a community,” Evoy said.

For each of the seven patients whose stories are featured in the report, prolonged hospitalization made their conditions worse, which in turn made it harder for them to find housing and services to meet their needs. 

Though Ria continues to fight for her daughter’s rights in court, the last 32 months of navigating Ontario’s healthcare and childcare systems while not being able to be by Arya’s side has taken its toll.

“Her health has been irreversibly damaged,” Ria said. “My daughter continues to decline. I don’t fully know how severe it is but I worry there isn’t much hope for her or our situation.”

 

Our journalism is powered by readers like you.

We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.

Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.

 

Become a member
Brishti Basu
Health Reporter
Eric Wickham
Ontario Reporter
Eric Wickham is PressProgress' Ontario reporter. His reporting focuses on housing, food security and education.

Most Shared

Second Sons ANALYSIS

Why the Flight Attendants’ Strike Was 'A Perfect Storm' for Labour

Related Stories

NEWS

Pediatric patients with complex chronic illnesses impacted by BC’s quiet changes to virtual care

View the post
NEWS

Lawsuit alleges top executive hired to address sexual harassment in BC paramedicine terminated while on maternity leave

View the post
NEWS

BC teachers say public education is being overlooked in the provincial election campaign

View the post
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.