Tim-Cartmell-campaign-launch-Global-News
Tim-Cartmell-campaign-launch-Global-News This article is more than 1 year old
Analysis

How the Development Industry Helped One Edmonton Mayoral Candidate Get a Head Start

Before nominations even opened, Tim Cartmell raised nearly half a million dollars, with roughly half coming from sources with apparent connections to real estate, construction and development

It didn’t take long for Edmonton mayoral candidate Tim Cartmell to amass a half-million-dollar war chest, before the election’s nomination period even began. And PressProgress has found that roughly half of that amount came from entities tied to real estate and suburban development.

Under the rules for Alberta’s municipal elections, a prospective candidate can start raising money before nominations open in January of an election year, so long as they submit a notice of intent. For the election coming up on Oct. 20, Cartmell submitted his notice last November. Campaign disclosures covering funds raised in November and December were published by the City of Edmonton earlier this year.

Cartmell’s disclosure for 2024 shows no fewer than 53 donations coming from sources with apparent ties to suburban development, with all but eight giving the maximum amount of $5,000.

“The Tim Cartmell and Better Edmonton campaigns have received donations from hundreds of individuals and corporations,” campaign manager Alex Hwyciw told PressProgress. “When all the donations have been disclosed by all campaigns, we will be in a better position to comment on the specifics.”

Out of the $447,265 that Cartmell’s campaign raised in 2024, almost $223,000 came from people and companies connected to real estate, construction and development interests, well before most of his opponents entered the race.

This doesn’t include an additional $15,000 that the campaign refunded to three companies linked to D.I.A Holdings, a development company heading a large network of entities owned by developer J. Cameron Allard.

They were:

  • Keswick Landing Ltd., $5,000
  • Southpointe Estates Inc., $5,000
  • Cameron Heights Joint Venture, $5,000

(Cameron Heights Joint Venture doesn’t appear to exist as a corporate entity, but previously their website linked directly to Allard Developments.)

The province brought in new municipal-campaign financing rules last year that clarified when separate, associated companies should be considered a single corporation due to overlap in ownership or control. Hwyciw told PressProgress that the news rules had “caused some confusion, but the funds were properly returned before the disclosure deadline.”

Southpointe Estates and Keswick Landing are both directed by the same two individuals, according to corporate filings: Paul Allard and Brad Clough. As it happens, each also individually donated $5,000.

This isn’t a first for the group of companies. In 2022, Allard-tied corporations poured over $100,000 into a pro-Danielle Smith third-party advertising campaign that ran ads during hockey games as the “Alberta First Initiative,” despite a $30,000 contribution limit, through a similar combination of entities.

The Allard Group didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Separately, three contributors share names with members of the family behind Cameron Developments.

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Tim Cartmell (@timcartmell)

Alberta municipalities will hold elections on October 20. Statements of contributions received from January through July were due at the end of September, but have not yet been posted to Edmonton’s elections site. Among the 13 candidates for mayor, Cartmell is one of just three who began collecting contributions in 2024; Omar Mohammad, who raised the second most in that period, brought in $20,650, or about 5% of Cartmell’s total. (Most candidates began their campaigns this past spring or summer.)

Recent polling by Abacus Data suggests Cartmell is currently the favourite to win, garnering the support of 39% of decided likely voters, an 11-point lead over his nearest competitor, Andrew Knack, whose support Abacus puts at 28%. Polling shows Cartmell’s strongest support is in the 45+ demographic.

Cartmell is part of a slate of candidates running under the “Better Edmonton” banner in Alberta’s new party system.

Better Edmonton launched in May and soon presented a full slate, along with a platform that heavily emphasizes law enforcement.

The party is led by Cartmell, a city councillor since 2017, who strangely claims he opposes municipal parties.

Cartmell has recently appeared to be at odds with his own slate for failing to show up to a key council vote regarding infill density limits early in the summer.

Better Edmonton is a project of the highly active political operative Stephen Carter, who has worked for former Calgary mayor Naheed Nenshi, Premier Danielle Smith, former Premier Allison Redford, Calgary Mayor Jyoti Gondek and the centre-right, pro-business Alberta Party.

The party is currently accepting donations, allowing individuals to contribute to both the party and candidates, though its funding hasn’t yet been disclosed.

Most recently, Carter served as chief of staff to Gondek before abruptly leaving the role with a six-figure severance package.

Edmonton Mayor Amarjeet Sohi is not running for reelection, leaving Edmonton’s election an open field.

In a recent statement, accountability group Public Interest Alberta raised a red flag about the transparency of political donations coming from the city’s largest corporations. PIA calls for a ban on all corporate and union donations.

By the time contributions collected in 2025 are eventually disclosed, “It’s already too late,” Hans Smits, University of Calgary professor emeritus and chair of the PIA Democracy Task Force, told PressProgress. “We don’t know where Cartmell’s money is coming from. We know he garners a lot of money, and that’s a real problem for democracy.”

Edmonton Elections is the nonpartisan office within the City of Edmonton responsible for administering the election, though in a statement they referred PressProgress to Elections Alberta regarding the lawfulness of multiple donations.

Alberta’s ministry of Municipal Affairs confirmed to PressProgress that making contributions on behalf of multiple, related companies may be unlawful under new rules in the province’s Local Authorities Election Act.

“It depends on how the corporation is structured. Whether a group of companies is treated as one entity or several depends on how they are controlled and by whom,” ministry spokesperson Michael Francoeur told PressProgress. The law follows the definition of an associated corporation laid out in the federal Income Tax Act.

As for Better Edmonton, Cartmell recently said the party will “go dormant” after the election.

Advance voting begins Tuesday.

 

Our journalism is powered by readers like you.

We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.

Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.

 

Become a member
Stephen Magusiak
Alberta Reporter
Stephen Magusiak is a reporter with PressProgress based in Alberta. His reporting has a focus on public accountability, public services and privatization, and the right-wing war on environmentalists.

Most Shared

Second Sons ANALYSIS

Why the Flight Attendants’ Strike Was 'A Perfect Storm' for Labour

Related Stories

ANALYSIS

‘Resurgence’ of racism and xenophobia in Canada’s policies a result of ‘growing and systemic racial hatred,’ experts say

View the post
ANALYSIS

How did the BC Conservatives turn Surrey blue?

View the post
ANALYSIS

Some BC residents wait five years to get connected with a doctor, here’s how politicians plan to change that

View the post
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.
Get our award-winning journalism directly in your inbox for free by signing up below.
Never miss a scoop again.