University of Toronto building shut down, police investigating threat, amid backlash to professor’s X post
While Ruth Marshall's comments were widely characterized as having concerned Charlie Kirk, evidence suggests a different context
A building housing several humanities departments at the University of Toronto has been shut down until Monday, following an intense backlash against a professor whose office is located there.
The professor, Ruth Marshall, who is reportedly now on leave, had tweeted comments that media platforms and activists on the right and far right had interpreted as celebrating the death of Charlie Kirk.
According to an email sent to faculty in the building by a department head Thursday afternoon, “U of T has made the decision to shut down the Jackman Humanities Building (170 St. George St.) for the remainder of today, Sept. 11, 2025, and tomorrow, Sept. 12, 2025 out of an abundance of caution following online comments. The building will be closed until Monday and Campus Safety is on location.”
A message on the university’s UTogether community webpage echoed this, and added that staff, faculty and students working and studying in the building were being “asked to leave and work from home or elsewhere for these two days.”
Classes at the Jackman Humanities Building were cancelled, relocated or moved online. A sign at the building’s entrance on Friday indicated that it was “locked.”

A sign visible at the Jackman Humanities Building on Friday. (Photo: Jonathan Goldsbie / PressProgress)
Contact information that had included an office address for Marshall, an associate professor in the departments of religion and political science, was removed from several U of T web pages as of Thursday.
When asked if any threats towards the school or individuals involved in the matter were made known to the Toronto Police Service, a TPS spokesperson told PressProgress that “a report has been made to police and the matter is being investigated.”
In an email to PressProgress, a U of T spokesperson said only, “Students were not in immediate danger,” and referred to the statement on the UTogether page.
At the centre of the controversy is an X post that Marshall apparently made on Wednesday afternoon in response to a user denying the authenticity of graphic videos showing children being killed in Gaza.
“Shooting is honestly too good for so many of you fascist c*nts,” it read (with the word spelled in full).
After a screenshot was shared by a far-right media figure who described the comment as a reaction to Kirk’s assassination, Marshall denied that it was about Kirk but rather “atrocity denial in Gaza.” She tweeted her own screenshot of the post in what appears to be its original context, a thread that began with a user contrasting reaction to the spread of graphic footage of Kirk’s assassination with the regularity of graphic footage coming out of Gaza. Another user described the latter as “weak ass propaganda with lame props,” to which Marshall offered the remark about shooting being “too good” for fascists. (Marshall’s X account has since been set to private, but captures of some of her posts appear on archive.today. The post that she was apparently responding to is still available.)
On Thursday, Marshall’s post was picked up by Toronto Sun columnist Joe Warmington, whose resulting story described it as being about Kirk, and quoted Ontario Premier Doug Ford as saying in response to it: “Disgusting. Sick people.”
The front page of Friday’s Toronto Sun carries the headline, “Prof who said ‘shooting is too good’ for Kirk put on leave by U of T.”
When contacted by PressProgress, Warmington said he did not see the tweet in which Marshall offered a different context for her comment but said that “if there’s something we should add context to, we will.”
Nolan Quinn, Ontario’s Minister of Colleges, Universities, Research Excellence and Security, also weighed in online.
Universities and their professors are supposed to foster critical thought, respectful debate, and be safe learning environments – and this professor’s violent rhetoric flagrantly flies in the face of that.
I’ve been clear with the University of Toronto: they need to act.…
— Nolan Quinn (@nolanmquinn) September 11, 2025
“Universities and their professors are supposed to foster critical thought, respectful debate, and be safe learning environments – and this professor’s violent rhetoric flagrantly flies in the face of that,” read his tweet linking to the Sun story. “I’ve been clear with the University of Toronto: they need to act.”
Quinn and Ford have not been the only Canadian politicians reacting to the discourse surrounding the killing of Kirk. Conservative MP Andrew Scheer accused independent journalist Rachel Gilmore of being “twisted” and “hateful,” after she made a tweet explaining her concern that the far right could use Kirk’s death to violently retaliate against their political opponents.
Marshall, the Premier’s Office and Minister Quinn did not respond to questions from PressProgress.
Our journalism is powered by readers like you.
We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.
Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.
Become a member
@ericwickham.ca