20 Ontario Long-Term Care Homes Owned by Chartwell Racked Up a Hundred Regulatory Infractions Last Year
Ministry records show 20 Chartwell long-term care homes in Ontario received 99 written notifications for ‘non-compliance’ in 2020
Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care inspectors cited 20 LTC homes owned by Chartwell’s nearly a hundred times for non-compliance last year, including cases where the company allegedly failed to address abuse, prevent injuries, maintain facilities or contain the spread of COVID-19.
An analysis by PressProgress of Ministry inspection reports finds the company, chaired by former Ontario Premier Mike Harris, racked up 99 non-compliance notifications at 20 of its 23 LTC homes in 2020 alone.
The Ministry defines “non-compliance” as a situation where “an inspector finds that a licensee has not complied with a requirement under the Act and or the associated regulations.”
In December, CBC News reported Chartwell homes had 4.6 deaths per 100 beds, among the highest average death rates in Canada. While that was lower than some other for-profit LTC companies, it’s significantly above the municipally-owned average of 1.4.
The Ontario government’s Science Advisory Table acknowledges “ownership” is a factor driving the conditions that increase deaths. Other experts note the drive for profits in private healthcare can push companies to understaff and crowd facilities, increasing profits at the risk of health.
In the case of Chartwell’s 23 Ontario for-profit homes, only three managed to clear 2020 without any non-compliance orders. The remainder averaged 4.3 orders per home, with some accounting for significantly more.
Among the worst-offenders are Chartwell’s Aurora LTC facility (12 violations), Royal Oak (15 violations), Woodhaven (13 violations) and Baycliffe (9 violations). Many of the non-compliance findings are not trivial infractions:
• Chartwell’s Aurora facility was found in non-compliance following a December 1 inspection. Inspectors wrote the facility failed to “immediately” report and act to protect a resident from abuse.
• On July 8, inspectors found Chartwell’s Whitehead facility “failed to ensure that a person who had reasonable grounds to suspect abuse of a resident had occurred immediately reported the suspicion and the information upon which it was based to the Director.”
• On February 27, Chartwell’s Wynfield facility reportedly received five notifications of non-compliance. Inspectors reported that the facility failed to “ensure that at least one registered nurse who is both an employee of the licensee and a member of the regular nursing staff of the home is on duty and present in the home at all times.”
• Chartwell’s Woodhaven LTC facility was notified of several infractions related to a COVID-19 outbreak at the home. The December 2020 reports during an outbreak at the home:
“There were inconsistent IPAC practices from the staff of the home, no housekeeper on the unit designated for positive residents and inconsistent supply of PPE outside of residents rooms, there was actual harm to the residents of the home. The risk associated to the staff not adhering to the homes IPAC program would be possible transmission of infectious agents during the ongoing outbreak in the home.”
The report states inspectors observed trash cans overflowing with used PPE as well as an inconsistent supply and use of PPE by staff and managers. During the outbreak, the report states that there was “no housekeeper on the unit designated for positive residents” — in fact, there was no housekeeper that day at all.
Instead, it largely fell to staff. In other cases, the report notes: “An RPN indicated that they observed the housekeeping manager cleaning the high touch surfaces once during their shift.”
• On December 31, inspectors found the company’s Trilogy LTC facility failed to adequately protect residents from infectious disease. On nearly all of the facility’s seven floors, inspectors found that staff faced shortages of PPE and virox wipes.
Additionally, a personal support worker was found entering the room of an “ill” resident wearing two regular masks rather than a standard N95 mask. The PSW said they felt they had no choice because they were crunched for time.
Chartwell did not respond to requests for comment from PressProgress.
Pat Armstrong, a York University professor and long-term care policy expert, said many of the regulations put in place by the provincial government were largely designed to manage the media fallout of scandals in LTC homes.
“Nothing much seems to happen when they are notified of non-compliance,” Armstrong told PressProgress.
Help us protect Canadians by holding the powerful accountable.
Journalism is an important public service. That’s why PressProgress is prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable during the coronavirus pandemic.
Please consider supporting our award-winning non-profit news organization so we can keep making a positive impact for Canadians.
Support Our Journalism