The Union That Doesn’t Like Confrontation
The Christian Labour Association of Canada (CLAC) prefers to work with, not against, employers. So what happens when workers want something different?
When Edmonton Strathcona MP and NDP leadership candidate Heather McPherson introduced a bill to ban “company unions” in the legislature last month, she singled out one union in particular: the Christian Labour Association of Canada (CLAC).
“The CLAC is the largest organization in Canada that is often referred to as a company union,” McPherson said at a press conference after tabling the private member’s bill. “Workers represented by the CLAC have told me that they feel powerless and unrepresented.”
The Fair Representation Act, or Bill C-259, would amend the Canada Labour Code to allow for unions that are “dominated or influenced by an employer or a person acting on behalf of an employer” to be de-certified pending an inquiry by the Canada Industrial Relations Board.
The following day, CLAC’s executive director, Wayne Prins, released a statement criticizing the bill for not providing protections for workers “that don’t already exist in every labour code in Canada.”
“McPherson’s bill and desperate attempts to discredit CLAC are about clinching support for her leadership bid,” Prins said in the statement.
McPherson’s bill comes on the heels of what the International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE) has called the largest exodus from CLAC in Canadian history. In late November of last year, 815 workers at OEM Remanufacturing in Edmonton voted to leave CLAC and instead join IUOE Local 955. This took place after a year of organizing and following demands for better union representation.
“This is a really unique case, in that they weren’t upset about the way their employer was treating them, and they weren’t upset with their financial package,” Chris Flett, business manager for IUOE Local 955, told PressProgress.
Rather, Flett said, these workers left CLAC because they were “completely unsatisfied with the level of representation they’ve been receiving.” (Asked about this, CLAC pointed to previous statements by their executive director, which included the observation that “workers who aren’t satisfied with their union, including with CLAC, should be free to choose another.”)
CLAC represents over 60,000 workers in five provinces and is currently certified by labour relations boards in Ontario, British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba. Most of the union’s membership is concentrated in the building trades and in healthcare.
But CLAC isn’t a member of any of the country’s labour institutions, like the Canadian Labour Congress or the provinces’ labour federations and building trades councils. In fact, the union’s “conciliatory approach” to bargaining with employers is at odds with much of the rest of the Canadian labour movement.
“An extreme form of accommodationist unionism”
In a 2017 article published in Labour/Le Travail, York University professors Steven Tufts and Mark Thomas described CLAC as “an extreme form of accommodationist unionism,” where compromise with employers is sought first and foremost, and conflict, especially strike action, is explicitly discouraged.
“They are actually proud that they have a relationship with employers that is more accommodationist or cooperative and non-confrontational,” Tufts told PressProgress.
CLAC describes itself as believing in “cooperation, not confrontation” and that strike action should only be used as a “last resort.”
As part of their research, Tufts and Thomas analyzed labour relations board cases from Ontario and Alberta involving CLAC. They found the majority of cases were related to certification, bargaining rights and jurisdictional conflicts, as opposed to day-to-day member grievances.
Often, these cases involved a question of union representation in the construction trades, “and unfavourable decisions were losses not to employers but to other construction unions,” wrote Tufts and Thomas (emphasis in original).
This data pointed to what the authors identified as the main source of tension between CLAC and the larger Canadian labour movement: raiding, which is when a union applies to represent workers who are already represented by another union.
Raiding is a more common practice in the trades, with some provinces having regular “raiding periods” during which workers can apply to decertify with their current union in order to join another. In other sectors, raiding is a contentious practice.
Another way CLAC organizes, according to Tufts, is working with employers.
“If an employer thinks they’re going to be unionized anyway because of external pressure or just internal movement within their own workforce, some are quite open to signing a quick deal or allowing CLAC to come in and be certified,” explained Tufts. “So they keep other unions out.”

Efforts to organize workers at the Executive Hotel Le Soleil Vancouver were at the centre of a series of BC Labour Relations Board decisions last summer. (screenshot via Google Street View)
A recent decision by the BC Labour Relations Board (BCLRB) in a case involving CLAC, Unite Here Local 40 and Executive Hotels and Resorts concluded that CLAC was brought in to thwart organizing by other unions.
Executive Hotels and Resorts owns a number of hotels in the Lower Mainland, four of which have been certified under CLAC since at least the mid-1990s. But Executive-owned hotels in Vancouver’s downtown core and on the North Shore, most of which have been built in the last decade, have remained non-union.
According to the August 2025 decision from the labour board, after Local 40 distributed union flyers at Le Soleil, an Executive Hotels-owned property, the director of human resources for the Executive Group of Companies sent an email to a CLAC representative about creating a collective agreement for the Le Soleil and Seaside hotels.
“The fact that the employer’s first email on the subject corresponds with the first day Local 40 was at Le Soleil would be an extraordinary coincidence without some explanation,” wrote BCLRB vice-chair Jonathan Hanvelt in his decision.
Hanvelt also noted that CLAC and Executive Group’s owners had agreed to the terms of the collective agreement, which in this case was a voluntary recognition agreement, before those terms had been shared with any of the hotel’s workers.
Voluntary recognition agreements allow employers and unions to mutually agree that a union will be the exclusive bargaining agent for a group of workers without the requirement that workers vote to certify the union or ratify the collective agreement. These relationships and agreements “exist largely outside” the domain of labour relations boards.
The BCLRB ruled against Executive Hotels and Resorts, finding that the hotel’s owners signed a voluntary recognition agreement with CLAC in order to block Local 40’s organizing. “The Employer’s decision to enter into the Voluntary Recognition Agreement compromised the employees’ ability to exercise their free choice of bargaining agent,” Hanvelt wrote. He found that this constituted an unfair labour practice on the part of the employer and dismissed CLAC’s application for certification.
Executive Group did not respond to requests for comment from PressProgress.
In an email to PressProgress, CLAC communications director André van Heerden wrote that the union disagrees with the decision and has an application for certification at the Le Soleil hotel that is currently before the BCLRB. He noted that the terms of the collective agreement CLAC negotiated remain in effect and said it was “ratified with 99% support from the membership.”
Mike Biskar has worked for Unite Here for the past 20 years, 10 of which have been with Local 40. He contrasted CLAC’s approach to labour relations with the way that unions like Unite Here organize.
“We go to workplaces because the workers call us,” said Biskar. “But in CLAC’s case, they go because the company calls.”
The BCLRB decision found that Executive Hotel Group management and their contact at CLAC discussed the wage rates that Unite Here Local 40 had bargained at other downtown Vancouver hotels. Biskar said workers were offered a substantial raise when CLAC membership was presented to them. He said he thinks those deals misled workers into voting in favour of a union just to get a raise.
(“We have outstanding relationships with our members in Exec Hotels throughout the province, many of whom we have represented for decades,” said CLAC’s van Heerden.)
Tufts said that CLAC’s Christian principles, like the organization’s commitment to working “with” employers and not striking, could appeal to the trades’ conservative workers.
The idea of strike action being a last resort could appeal to healthcare providers who “see themselves as necessary, essential, they care about their clients,” said Tufts.
“Strikes break the relationship between employers and employees, and hurts their ability to work well together in the future,” wrote van Heerden. “However, when no just solution can be found, CLAC does support strike action.” He noted that in November 2023, educational assistants with the Hanover School Division in Steinbach, Manitoba, who are represented by CLAC, went on strike for three weeks.
Founded in 1952 by Dutch immigrants, the Christian Labour Association of Canada emerged from the Dutch Reform Church and the European Christian labour tradition.
Almost 185,000 people left the Netherlands for Canada between the late 1940s and the 1970s. While Dutch Roman Catholic and secular immigrants integrated into existing institutions in Canadian society, Reformists didn’t have institutions to turn to — so they created their own.
Redeemer University College, a network of elementary schools, DUCA credit union and the CLAC were just some of the Dutch Reformed institutions they founded.
According to CLAC’s website, the union’s founders saw CLAC as an alternative to the “chaotic” Canadian labour landscape, which they saw as defined by “strikes, lockouts, violence” and a “politics of fear.”
CLAC’s constitution was modelled after that of the Christian Labor Association of the United States, which was established two decades earlier. While CLAC’s constitution does not require union members to be Christian, it says that the union “bases its policies and actions on the Christian principles of social justice and charitable relationships among people, as taught in the Bible.”
“How we practice representing workers is based on Christian social principles,” wrote van Heerden.
The union’s religious affiliation became an issue in the 1950s, when CLAC’s Hamilton, Ontario, local applied for certification to represent workers at Bosch and Keuning Limited, the publisher of a Dutch-language magazine called Home and Family.
The Ontario Labour Relations Board ruled that the requirement for members to adhere to Christian doctrine served “to impose restrictions on eligibility for membership,” and suggested that the CLAC consider the anti-discrimination clauses in the Labour Relations Act before submitting another application to the board.
According to a Hamilton Spectator article from the time, the board noted that the union’s aim was “the practical application of Christian principles in collective bargaining.”
Franz Fuykchot, CLAC’s then-general secretary, argued that members “must apply Christian principles in their work, not their life. That makes a difference.”
Fuykchot told the Spectator that while the ruling was a “disappointing setback,” the union would not change the principal parts of its constitution.
The following decade, Ontario’s high court overruled an OLRB decision that denied CLAC the right to represent workers at Tange Construction in Trenton. CLAC’s lawyers had argued that an adherence to secularism was no less biased than CLAC’s principles, and that the focus on class struggle in many unions’ constitutions was similarly not neutral.
Tufts said that the difference in ideology, and CLAC’s “last resort” approach to striking, are what really matter to employers.
After a year of organizing and two days of voting, IUOE 955 business manager and director of organizing Anthony Noseworthy said in a statement that his union was excited to show the former CLAC members “what a real union can do for them.”
Biskar, of Unite Here, said he understands why employers try to insulate themselves from union organizing in their workforces, but that from his experience, signing voluntary recognition agreements behind the scenes comes with a cost.
“When you bring in a company union, you introduce to the workers the idea of having a union, and then it’s a more natural thing for workers to say, ‘Well, if I’m going to be in a union, I ought to be in a good union,’” said Biskar.
Our journalism is powered by readers like you.
We’re an award-winning non-profit news organization that covers topics like social and economic inequality, big business and labour, and right-wing extremism.
Help us build so we can bring to light stories that don’t get the attention they deserve from Canada’s big corporate media outlets.
Become a member

@emmaarkell.bsky.social