coyne-electoralreform_thumb-1.png This article is more than 5 years old

VIDEO: Andrew Coyne needs only 5 short minutes to explain why Canada’s electoral system is broken

Coyne says Canada's current first-past-the post system "violates some pretty fundamental principles of democracy."


Andrew Coyne thinks Canada’s electoral system is broken.

And the National Post columnist needed only five minutes to explain why during a debate on electoral reform at the Broadbent Institute’s 2016 Progress Summit last weekend:

Along with former Clerk of the Privy Council Alex Himelfarb, Coyne advocated moving away from Canada’s current first-past-the post system – a system he suggests “violates some pretty fundamental principles of democracy” – in favour of proportional representation.

The Liberal Party’s platform promised that “2015 will be the last federal election conducted under the first-past-the-post-voting system,” but as Coyne’s latest column points out, “the suspicion lingers that more powerful figures in the prime minister’s office would not be overly concerned if it died the same death as other Liberal promises.”

But as far as Coyne’s concerned, maintaining the “status quo” should be out of the question.

Here are five quotable moments from Coyne’s introductory remarks explaining why Canada’s first-past-the-post system is broken:


“What I want to suggest is that many of the frustrations we have with how our politics works or doesn’t work are not inevitable but are products of that system, that the method of voting we think of as ‘normal’ is, in fact, highly abnormal, that indeed it violates some pretty fundamental principles of democracy.”


“Forgive me, but I think this is a pretty non-trivial objection: rule by the minority over the majority. We wouldn’t put up with it, say, in Parliament. If someone were to try to pass a law with the votes of only 39% of the Members of Parliament, I’d be willing to bet there’d be riots. So how is it any different if MPs representing only 39% of the people do likewise?”


“If ballots were issued to some voters but not others, or in packs of two or nine or twenty-nine, depending on which party you voted for and what riding you lived in, there’d be riots in the streets … In some provincial elections, the same phenomenon results in one party winning all seats in the house, or nearly so. What kind of democracy is one party and no opposition?”


“How else may we define democracy? Well, it’s a system in which you can vote for the party of your choice. Except you can’t as often as not in our system, not if you don’t want to split the vote. How often have you been told that you can’t vote for the party you prefer, but must vote for a party you don’t like to prevent a party you detest from getting in?”


“In sum, the present system allows the minority to rule over the majority, it gives some voters many times the voting power of others, it denies many voters the right to vote for the party of their choice and wastes the vote of many others. Oh, and it nearly killed the country a couple times, besides.


Other than that, it’s a pretty good system.” 

Photo: Broadbent Institute. 

Help us protect Canadians by holding the powerful accountable.

Journalism is an important public service. That’s why PressProgress is prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable during the coronavirus pandemic.

Please consider supporting our award-winning non-profit news organization so we can keep making a positive impact for Canadians.


Support Our Journalism
PressProgress is an award-winning non-profit news organization focused on uncovering and unpacking the news through original investigative and explanatory journalism.

Most Shared

thumb-2021-04-09 News

Jason Kenney’s New Education Curriculum Appears to Have Copy-Pasted Lines From Wikipedia

Related Stories


Ontario MPP Randy Hillier Does Not Disavow QAnon After Taking Photos With Conspiracy Theorists

View the post

Telus’ Call Centre for Booking Vaccine Appointments in British Columbia is ‘Disorganized’ and ‘Chaotic’, Former Workers Say

View the post

Saskatchewan Quietly Cut Funding For Provincial Office in Charge of Climate Change Policy

View the post


Human rights & inclusion

Amira Elghawaby

Canada is Bringing in New Legislation to Stop the Spread of Online Hate. Here’s How It Can Work.

View the post
Politics & strategy

Tom Parkin

Why is Erin O’Toole Pitching Conservatism to Working Class Voters?

View the post
Power and democracy

Andrea Reimer

Here’s How Canadians Can Keep Big Money Out of Politics

View the post