gg-johnston_thumb-1.png This article is more than 4 years old

It’s ‘Canada 150’ and our Governor General still doesn’t understand nation-to-nation relationships

Canada's Governor General is kicking off "Canada 150" by dedicating the first gaffe of the national sesquicentennial to "our quote, Indigenous people, unquote."


Canada’s Governor General is kicking off “Canada 150” celebrations by dedicating the first gaffe of the national sesquicentennial to “our quote, Indigenous people, unquote.”



Speaking to CBC Radio’s The House over the weekend, Governor General David Johnston attempted to explain what he thinks unifies Canadians by pointing out we are all “immigrants” – including “our quote, Indigenous people, unquote”:

“We’re a country based on immigration, going right back to our, quote, Indigenous people, unquote, who were immigrants as well, 10, 12, 14,000 years ago.”

Two days later, Johnston apologized at Rideau Hall.

While some questioned Johnston’s understanding of history (recent data suggests migration to North America may have occurred as much as 10,000 years earlier, though even his own timeline places this wave of “immigration” in the middle of the Stone Age) and others took issue with Johnston repeatedly implying possession over “our” Indigenous people, it’s also a pretty big deal that the Governor General is the representative of the Crown.

That’s significant because First Nations signed treaties with the Crown, not the Government of Canada.

As historian Nathan Tidridge has explained, Canada’s treaty relationships with Indigenous peoples are actually a “nation-to-nation relationship” between Indigenous peoples and the Crown – who is represented by the Governor General:

“Most Canadians don’t realize that for Indigenous Peoples, Canada’s place in its Treaty relationships is not fulfilled by the government of the day, but rather by the Crown—specifically the Queen … what people need to realize is that the relationship between the Sovereign and Indigenous Peoples is at the heart of any Treaty. The Queen, on behalf of Canadians, is bound in Treaties across the land, cementing familial relationships with First Nations … If Canada is truly committed to reconciling a nation-to-nation relationship, then the Crown that allowed this country to germinate in these lands needs to be understood and embraced so we can restore ourselves as Treaty people.”

And one of the key building blocks of that relationship includes the recognition that Indigenous people had “prior standing as fully independent, sovereign entities.”

In other words, it doesn’t matter if anybody arrived “10, 12, 14,000 years ago,” the Crown already recognized independent, sovereign nations were already using and occupying the land before Europeans arrived.

As the 1992 Royal Commission on Aboriginal Affairs put it: 

“Aboriginal peoples were the first inhabitants of this continent and the original custodians of its lands and resources. As a result of long-standing use and occupation, they have continuing rights in the land. They also hold the status of self-governing nations by virtue of their prior standing as fully independent, sovereign entities. This sovereignty was manifested originally in the international relations that Aboriginal nations maintained with one another. After contact, it was also recognized in practice by incoming European powers, as they competed among themselves to establish favourable alliances and trading relations with Aboriginal peoples. The sovereignty of Aboriginal nations did not come to an end when colonial governments were established.” 

So, if the Governor General redefines Indigenous people as “immigrants,” that’s distorting the original meaning of the nation-to-nation relationship set out in law.

Johnston isn’t the only Canadian who might be missing that context.

For example, the National Post’s John Ivision recently used the incident to complain about “grievance culture” and “mob outrage,” suggesting the Governor General “used the culturally loaded term “immigrant’, instead of the more neutral term ‘migrant’.”

Actually, no  the Governor General’s words do matter.


Help us protect Canadians by holding the powerful accountable.

Journalism is an important public service. That’s why PressProgress is prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable during the coronavirus pandemic.

Please consider supporting our award-winning non-profit news organization so we can keep making a positive impact for Canadians.


Support Our Journalism
PressProgress is an award-winning non-profit news organization focused on uncovering and unpacking the news through original investigative and explanatory journalism.

Most Shared

Thumb-2021-07-25 Explainer

Ontario PC MPP Floats Idea of Replacing Teachers With Pre-Recorded Videos To Cut Education Costs

Related Stories


Why Is The Pandemic’s Economic Harm Disproportionately Impacting Young Women?

View the post

Neo-Nazi was a Guest at a Swanky Fundraising Dinner for a Right-Wing Charity That Tried to Dig Up Dirt on a Canadian Judge

View the post

Justin Trudeau Announced 302 ‘Affordable’ Rental Units Will Be Built in Brampton. The Developer is Only Building 72.

View the post


Emma Arkell

Why Is The Pandemic’s Economic Harm Disproportionately Impacting Young Women?

View the post
Human rights & inclusion

Amira Elghawaby

Canada is Holding an Emergency Summit to Take Action Against Islamophobia. Here’s What’s at Stake for Canadian Muslims.

View the post
Politics & strategy

Tom Parkin

How Justin Trudeau’s Inaction Undermined The Coalition Calling For Paid Sick Leave

View the post