This article is more than 4 years old

VIDEO: Fraser Institute expert tells business elites Hong Kong is the freest place in the world

According to the Fraser Institute, Hong Kong (a place that doesn't allow free elections) is the freest place in the world.

March 28, 2016


Where is the freest place in the world?

According to this guy from the Fraser Institute: Hong Kong, a place that doesn’t allow free elections.

Addressing a gala dinner for Hong Kong’s business elites a few months ago, Fred McMahon, Fraser Institute’s Chair in “Economic Freedom,” declared Hong Kong “number one in overall freedom” in the world:

The right-wing Fraser Institute has repeatedly ranked Hong Kong the “most economically free” country in the world – no free elections, but hey: no capital gains tax either!

In the midst of the 2014 pro-democracy “umbrella” protests, Hong Kong’s Chinese-backed administration released a statement saying they “welcomed the Fraser Institute again ranking Hong Kong the world’s freest economy,” and added that the rankings validate “the city’s steadfast commitment to free market principles.”

However, McMahon’s comments at the Lion Rock Institute Gala Dinner go one extra step further, outright declaring Hong Kong the world’s freest place in terms of “overall freedom”:

“What my Institute, the Fraser Institute – in cooperation with the Cato Institute in the United States and the Friedrich Naumann Foundation for Freedom in Germany – have done is produce the first ever index that measures all dimensions of freedom: economic freedom, civil freedom, freedom of association. And when you put them altogether I’m glad to tell you that Hong Kong is number one in overall freedom too.”

And although McMahon did express concern about a possible decline in “the rule of law,” McMahon bizarrely assured the business crowd that the rule of law has in Hong Kong has “declined at the same pace as it has in Canada” and, besides, the rule of law has “declined far more dramatically in the United States.”

Wait, what?

This is not the first time McMahon has shared his thoughts about democracy in Hong Kong.

Explaining why Hong Kong sits at the top of the Fraser Institute’s 2014 “economic freedom” rankings despite the fact “Hong Kong has never been a deomcracy,” McMahon urged readers of the National Post not to equate democracy with freedom:

“Economic freedom, not democracy, has driven Hong Kong’s exceptional growth. It is important to remember that democracy and freedom are not the same thing. Democracy is a power structure; freedom is the ability to do what you want with your life.”

In fact, the Fraser Institute, which is a registered charity, has even published research arguing “autocratic regimes” can make you happy – yes, happy!

According to a report published last year, the Fraser Institute claimed people who “feel they are in control of their lives positively correlates with personal life satisfaction.”

After comparing democracies against “autocratic regimes,” the Fraser Institute concluded “democratic institutions are not relevant for an enhanced feeling of life control” while “the feeling of being in control of one’s own life” is “comparatively higher under autocratic regimes.”

The Fraser Institute’s “Economic Freedom Index” has some high profile critics, including researchers at the United Nations’ International Labour Organization, who’ve repeatedly criticized (see here and here) the Institute’s ranking system for having “a strong conceptual bias.”


Photo: Lion Rock Institute.


Journalism is an important public service. That’s why we’re prioritizing stories aimed at keeping Canadians safe and holding the powerful accountable.


No, Conservatives: the Liberals did not announce a “nightmare” tax & spend budget from the 1970s

If you listen to interim Conservative leader Rona Ambrose, she'll tell you it's a "nightmare scenario."

March 25, 2016


Is the 2016 budget really a “nightmare” tax and spend budget?

If you listen to interim Conservative leader Rona Ambrose, she’ll tell you the “spending spree” is a “nightmare scenario.”

And the right-wing Canadian Taxpayers Federation says if you had to pick a name for the budget, it should be named “Spendy McDebtface,” for some reason.

This framing of the budget has even managed to creep into media coverage, with CBC declaring “Liberals push…