fraserinstitute-ontario-minwage_thumb
fraserinstitute-ontario-minwage_thumb
Fact-Check

Fraser Institute Bombards Ontario With Ads Falsely Portraying Minimum Wage Workers as Teenagers

Sorry, Fraser Institute: four-in-five Ontarians who stand to lose out under Doug Ford’s minimum wage rollback are adults

June 22, 2018

As Premier-designate Doug Ford prepares to roll back Ontario’s minimum wage, the Fraser Institute is blanketing social media with misleading ads that falsely portray minimum wage workers as teenagers.

The right-wing think tank has spent years trying to discredit minimum wage increases by polluting the airwaves with false stereotypes of minimum wage workers as affluent teenagers living a life of luxury in their parent’s basements.

“Who earns the minimum wage in Ontario?” asks a new ad the Fraser Institute is currently running on Facebook. “It’s not who you think.”

The ad, which features cartoons of clean-cut teenage baristas and fast food workers, inaccurately claims the overwhelming majority of workers in Ontario who earn a minimum wage are actually “teenagers or young adults.”

Facebook

According to a linked report, the Fraser Institute argues minimum wage increases do not help “those in need” because minimum wage workers are “teenagers or youths living with family.”

Leaving aside that the right-wing think tank seems to be suggesting no one under 25 deserves a living wage or that parents should subsidize the labour costs of fast food chains and big corporations, the Fraser Institute’s numbers are highly misleading.

The Fraser Institute claims 59% of minimum wage workers are “teenagers or young adults” by lumping 15 year old high school students in with 24 year old adults, even though a 15 year old and a 24 year old have wildly different life circumstances.

According to Statistics Canada data from 2017, only 38% of minimum wage workers were teenagers. The overwhelming majority were legally adults: 21% were in their early 20s, 41% were 25 years and older – in fact, one in ten minimum wage workers across Ontario were 55 years and older.

So, looked at another way, we can say 38% were teenagers while nearly two-thirds of minimum wage workers in Ontario were not teenagers (62%).

Statistics Canada, 2017

What’s more, those numbers only take into account anyone who earned the minimum wage in 2017 when it was $11.40 (and later $11.60) per hour.

Taking into account everyone who earned under $15/hour, the picture looks a lot different – four in five Ontarians who would benefit from raising the minimum wage to $15/hour are not teenagers.

In all, only 18% of workers earning less than $15/hour are teenagers while 81% are not teenagers, including 58% who are over the age of 25.

Statistics Canada, 2017

The Fraser Institute also fails to consider the ripple effect of raising the minimum wage and how that puts upward pressure on all wages across the labour market.

A 2017 study published by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives found that “baby boomers are about as likely as teenagers” to get a raise from a minimum wage increase to $15 an hour, with the vast majority of those benefiting employed at large companies with over 500 employees.

 

Invest in our work

We break news and shine a light on stories Canada’s major media outlets miss. But we need your help to keep making an impact.

Subscribe to our Friday Newsletter

Too busy to follow the daily news? Get the inside scoop on the entire week’s news sent to your email inbox every Friday at noon.

Invest in our work

We break news and shine a light on stories Canada’s major media outlets miss. But we need your help to keep making an impact.

Cannabis gavel
Cannabis gavel
Analysis

500,000 Canadians Have Old Criminal Records for Pot Possession. Trudeau Won’t Commit to Pardon Them.

Critics accuse Trudeau government of being more interested in commercializing cannabis than civil liberties

June 21, 2018

Canada has officially become the second country in the world to legalize cannabis.

While Justin Trudeau’s Liberal Party is busy using the legislation as an opportunity for partisan fundraising, Trudeau’s party has very little to say about hundreds of thousands of Canadians whose lives are impacted by old criminal records for possessing a substance that will soon be sold in stores.

On Wednesday, Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould and Liberal pot czar Bill Blair